ORIGINAL: John 3rd
Well...that is disappointing...I had hoped it was a technical as well as political/economic work. I'll drop it about 10 spaces on my 'to buy' list.
The Willmott that I have heard so much about is Barrier Against the Javelin. I have heard it to be fantastic. Agree/Disagree?
I get the Willmotts mixed up ... looking ... ok ... B&J is the second one, which mostly covers Coral Sea and Midway. I'd say for 30 or so years ago when it was written, it was fantastic. But now a days, with works like Lundstrom running around, I'd say B&J is pretty much just another classical, fairly high level description of the battle.
But the other one of the pair Empires in the Balance, spends a whole lot more time off the shelf and on my desk. This is because is contains a good description of the land combat in Malaya. At least better than anything else I have.
Perhaps the most lasting aspect of Willmott's work however, is his strategic assessment of the Japanese options in earl 1942. Either go East against the Americans, South against the Aussies or West against the Brito-Indians. He thinks the Japanese should have gone against the Brito-Indians. And this is because, as a Brit he sees that Indian was so very weak that if pushed it should have been easy to take. And I heard this same view from my father when I was a child. My father was in the RN stationed in Ceylon and never understood why the Japanese didn't just take India. So Willmott echos that idea for sure.
I actually don't happen to agree, I think the Japanese clearly had one enemy, America and nothing else mattered if you didn't have a strategy to stop the Americans. But I don't have a good option for the Japanese either!
I certainly don't regret having Willmott's works on my shelf, they have been there since the early 80s. But knowing what I know a this stage, I would not rush out and buy them now. I would hunt for some of the newer works (or even the older ones) with more detail. At this stage, I'm not much looking for prose. Give me charts and tables - the REALLY DRY stuff!