Bug with Surprise March?

Hannibal: Rome and Carthage in the Second Punic War is a new and innovative turn-based strategy game that puts you in command of the Carthaginian military during a period of total war over land and sea with the young Roman Republic. With this military juggernaut of the ancient world at your disposal, you will vie for control over Italy, Carthage, Spain and the Mediterranean Sea using a combination of strategic political maneuvering and sheer tactical skill both on land and sea. Play consists of two layers; the first is a strategic layer where you must prudently steer your forces to the destruction of Rome’s army and the ultimate destruction of the Republic and city itself. At your disposal are a variety of unit types and historical commanders from which to form your armies. On the tactical scale, when meeting the enemy in battle, skilled leadership and a knack for war come into play as you use a simple but engaging battle system to best your opponents.

Moderator: mercenarius

Post Reply
mgdpublic
Posts: 25
Joined: Fri Dec 15, 2006 3:11 am

Bug with Surprise March?

Post by mgdpublic »

Perhaps I'm not understanding this card. I had Hannibal in Bruttium while Scipio was in Latium/Campania. I used Surprise March (because Hannibal was alone) to try to get him to link up with Mago in Latium/Campania but Scipio intervened every time. I had chosen Latium as my Surprise March place.

Also, is the manpower available a lot lower on Hard?

Thanks!

EDIT: One other question while I'm at it. The strategy guide recommends not taking mediolanum and patavium on the first turn. Why not? This prevents Rome from raising and allows Hannibal to use Gallic Aid.
User avatar
mercenarius
Posts: 739
Joined: Tue Jul 06, 2010 1:51 am

RE: Bug with Surprise March?

Post by mercenarius »

The Surprise March option was designed to allow Hannibal to march through a province without being intercepted. But it doesn't overrule the usual restrictions for combining armies.

So, no, this isn't a bug. But I can see that the manual could be more clear.

Good question, by the way! This is an option which didn't turn out to be as useful as I thought that it would be. Maybe the link-up you are trying should be legal? This might be another thing to put on the list of "one of these days I'll do another Hannibal Patch." [:)]
Also, is the manpower available a lot lower on Hard?

The available manpower in Africa is noticeably lower on Hard compared to the Introductory level. It should be the same as the "Normal" level.

Really, the manpower in Africa is increased significantly at the Introductory level to help new players. The other recruiting pools are not affected by the level of difficulty.
The strategy guide recommends not taking mediolanum and patavium on the first turn. Why not?

I felt that the player generally should not risk losing valuable units. My thinking was that it would usually be better to take one city and then play Gallic Aid after winning a battle.

Of course, there are a number of choices at the beginning of the game. Perhaps your way is better? I think that many players have designed strategies which are better than my own recommendations! [:D]
James Warshawsky
Forced March Games, LLC
mgdpublic
Posts: 25
Joined: Fri Dec 15, 2006 3:11 am

RE: Bug with Surprise March?

Post by mgdpublic »

Thanks for the quick reply! Actually I wasn't even originally linking up. At first I just put Hannibal alone in Latium and he was intercepted. So by "through", then do you mean "out of?" (because it doesn't work for "in to")

Strange about the manpower because I played my first game on Hard last night and I didn't have any manpower on the second turn in either spain or cisalpine gaul (I had New Carthage not under siege in spain and the three small cities in CG not under seige) Thought that was weird. Also, did you make the game easier? I noticed complaints about the difficulty and I won quite easily both times I played on Hard in less than 10 turns. Not bragging here - certainly don't consider myself a Hannibal :)
User avatar
mercenarius
Posts: 739
Joined: Tue Jul 06, 2010 1:51 am

RE: Bug with Surprise March?

Post by mercenarius »

At first I just put Hannibal alone in Latium and he was intercepted

I misunderstood your original post. That would be a bug. The "into" movement should not be intercepted if Hannibal is using Surprise March.

However, I am unable to duplicate this. When I use the card, Hannibal is not intercepted.

Do you happen to have a saved game which can duplicate your particular situation?
James Warshawsky
Forced March Games, LLC
User avatar
mercenarius
Posts: 739
Joined: Tue Jul 06, 2010 1:51 am

RE: Bug with Surprise March?

Post by mercenarius »

Also, did you make the game easier?

Not deliberately. [:D]

Seriously, I didn't do anything to adjust the difficulty of the game in the latest patch.

You may have found a chink in the AI's armor, so to speak. Or you just play a mean game. [8D]
I didn't have any manpower on the second turn in either spain or cisalpine gaul

Just to make sure: you did qualify for recruiting there? I.e., you had a general (not under siege) in each province? Forgive me for asking, but I just don't see how the recruiting pool in Spain or Cisalpine Gaul could be drained after one turn.

James Warshawsky
Forced March Games, LLC
Post Reply

Return to “Hannibal: Rome and Carthage in the Second Punic War”