I've been playing breakout and pursuit, and have completely ignored my normal micro-managing instincts; auto air-ad, blasting holes, and exploiting where possible and shuffling rail repair units forward. Once I let go of trying to understand what was going on, I've had the best time I've ever had with this game. At the risk of ruining all the fun that I've had, I have to say that there is still one little itch inside my brain which wants to see inside that secret black box of air and ground combat. While this question probably gets asked in one form or another all the time(so I apologize), this manic desire for complexity and control is what initially made me interested enough to shell out $80 for this game. With that being said, please bare with me (even if it is just to tell me to go back and enjoy the game) when I ask if there is any more info, beyond the manual, about what is happening in combat?
I'm not looking to predict the hits of every single element, but I am looking to predict broader patterns beyond just commander's instinct or it should work that way. The commander's report is a wealth of information that is just an absolute tease because in most cases I have no idea how the information goes together.
From the manual, my understanding is that the elements pick a distance (which is dependent upon the terrain), fire (depending upon their ammo, morale, ROF) and then maybe get hit in which case they can be disrupted, damaged or destroyed. Here's an example of how my understanding of the manual's description and the numbers from the commander report go together:
From my experiences in Operation Husky, I know that naval artillery absolutely wrecks. Whenever naval artillery is employed, the enemy disruption goes through the roof. I'm guessing that happens at range (prior to the enemy getting into range of my guys) as my losses are minimal. Beyond that, I have no idea how to compare most of the numbers I'm seeing. Let's look at the numbers for the 7.5 in Naval Gun available to the commonwealth.
Range: 21100. I'm assuming this is 21 km. Awesome, jives with my understanding that I shot them way before the could shoot me.
Ammo: 300. I'm assuming this is per fire? Makes sense that resupplying this is a hog based on what the manual says about logistics.
Then it gets less clear....
Anti-Soft: 420. ???? No idea what this is in relation too. I guess that's a good number for killing squishies like people. Maybe the naval gun also likes to blow a different kind of smoke, or is a secret Hitler fan? I speculate because the possibilities for this number being 420 are endless... and meaningless to me.
Anti-Armor: 105 ??? Armor values for units are supposed to be in mm. Maybe this can penetrate 105mm?
Penetration: 277 ??? Even more confused... Anti-armor and penetration are different?
Blast: 14 ?? Is there a spatial separation of units that is tracked in combat?
But wait there is more...
All ground units have a speed value. This makes sense for movement points, but one is left to wonder whether it factors into combat? Does combat move in rounds based on range (e.g. everything legal at 3000m can shoot now) or does it move in rounds based on time (e.g. round 1, infantry is at 3000m but tanks at 1000m).
How does the maneuver rating play into air combat and where did the magic, rest pilots at 60 fatigue come from?
Why are rockets (allegedly) better for interdiction versus dropping hundreds of small bombs everywhere with 4E planes?
I've dug around the forums quite a bit. I know the information is out there, and has a gameplay impact. I recall reading a forum where one of the devs stated that air-ground attacks above 5000 ft dive with FBs but make glide attacks under 5000ft. This behavior had an impact on strategies against different flak concentrations and affected decision making. I want to be empowered to make these decisions versus wondering what's happening and whether I need to drug test my 7.5 in naval guns.
So I know, I'm going to be told to go play the game and enjoy myself. I'm half telling myself to do that because this is a great game, and its worth $80. But if you do have information, and your willing to share.... oh man. I'd even settle for a combat debug window that I could watch.
Thanks in advance.