Matrix Games Forums

Forums  Register  Login  Photo Gallery  Member List  Search  Calendars  FAQ 

My Profile  Inbox  Address Book  My Subscription  My Forums  Log Out

How do I turn off automatic defensive behavior?

View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Logged in as: Guest
Users viewing this topic: none
  Printable Version
All Forums >> [Current Games From Matrix.] >> [Modern] >> Harpoon 3 - Advanced Naval Warfare >> How do I turn off automatic defensive behavior? Page: [1]
Message << Older Topic   Newer Topic >>
How do I turn off automatic defensive behavior? - 5/14/2007 4:29:43 AM   


Posts: 16
Joined: 5/13/2007
Status: offline
After a few days of trying to find out about what I thought was a bug, I find that it is a 'feature' built into H3.

My ship and aircraft radars come on by themselves and automatically fire at incoming threats.

Is there any way to make this stop?

To me this is an unacceptable behavior and I simply cannot play the game.
Post #: 1
RE: How do I turn off automatic defensive behavior? - 5/14/2007 1:34:06 PM   

Posts: 39
Joined: 2/19/2007
Status: offline
You can always use the weapons tight flag in the pref setup pull down


Old radar men never die - Their echoes fade away in accordance with the inverse fourth power law

(in reply to Flunkie)
Post #: 2
RE: How do I turn off automatic defensive behavior? - 5/15/2007 5:18:11 AM   


Posts: 16
Joined: 5/13/2007
Status: offline
I had been trying to find an answer to what I thought was a bug for several days. This automatic behavior where my ships and aircraft radars come on and missiles are fired at enemy aircraft and incoming missiles. From some of the answers I was getting I came to the conclusion that this was a built-in defensive 'feature' of the game and not a bug.

But, you are bringing up a question here. And I am again wondering if I have a bug or not.

I had played Harpoon AE for 10 years or whatever, and since way back when, I have always played with weapons tight. With weapons tight, nothing ever fired on its own, no matter how big the threat. If I remember correctly, when you played with weapons free the behavior was something like this:
Your aircraft and ships would fire at identified enemy aircraft.
Your aircraft and ships would fire at incoming missiles, perhaps identified or not.
Your ships would fire at identified enemy ships and boats when in range.
Your ships would fire at identified enemy land bases when in range.

Since I have been playing H3ANW v.3.8.0 (this did not happen with v.3.7) I have noticed, in all scenarios and the 3 DBs I have tried, the following:
My ship and aircraft radars come on and my aircraft fire at identified enemy aircraft.
My ship and aircraft fire at identified incoming missiles.
I believe my ships have fired harpoons at enemy boats.

About the only difference is that I have not seen my ships fire at enemy land bases.
It would seem that there is little to no deference between weapons tight and weapons free. So why have the weapons tight setting (which I much prefer) at all, which brings up the question of whether this is a bug or not.

I should say that I have perhaps noticed a difference with weapons tight in that the threat must be more immediate in most cases before weapons will be fired as opposed to if weapons were free.


I have always played with weapons tight and this does not help with v.3.8. Is it supposed to? I am now playing with all my Staff Handles off and this does not help either.

Do you play some version of H3 and are you not experiencing this behavior of weapons firing automatically in a defensive manor? I would sure like to know if you are not so that I may get my game to stop this.

I would very much like to hear from several people at least who play any version of H3, with weapons tight, and are not experiencing this behavior. Just drop a note here or PM me. Say something like 'I use H3 version xxx with weapons tight, and do not experience this behavior.' Or better yet a little stronger statement like 'nothing ever fires on its own.'

(in reply to Sirius.)
Post #: 3
RE: How do I turn off automatic defensive behavior? - 5/15/2007 10:31:50 PM   

Posts: 323
Joined: 5/12/2006
Status: offline
I experience the same behaviour as Flunkie.
I also tend to micromanage and use Plotted mission and weapons tight.

I prefer the 3.6 behaviour where the weapons tight means tight over the ANW behaviour where even on weapons tight shots can be fired by my units on plotted mission.

Just my preference

Post #: 4
RE: How do I turn off automatic defensive behavior? - 5/17/2007 3:32:26 AM   


Posts: 16
Joined: 5/13/2007
Status: offline

I was wondering when this 'feature' and or bug began. Apparently 3.6 did not do this and it is a new behavior to 3.7 or 3.8. I have played Harpoon AE for many years, and there also, weapons tight meant just that.

I too much prefer weapons to be tight. (That doesn't sound quit right.)

FreekS--- See below about putting ships on a mission.


Gees, after writing all this and just about to post, I noticed your comment about putting your ships on a mission. That sounds like it will help alot if I simply tell them to 'go there.'
I will leave the rest of what I wrote just in case any of it still has some meaning.
_ _ _ _ _ _

You sound official. As though you are connected with Maxis. Is that so? (not rhetorical) While I very much appreciate help and suggestions from other players, it is also nice to hear something 'official.' I was beginning to wonder if Maxis had any official support for Harpoon. I couldn't find it.

I will write as though you are someone official. And thank you for your response by the way.

(I am adding this note here because I have read some of what I have written below and it sounds to much as though I am complaining. Well, I may be complaining just a little, but mainly I am just trying to let you know what is happening. And I am adding a few thoughts and opinions.)

Ooooookay.... No, I don't want my ships defending themselves. At least not without my permission. And not in the way they are doing so. I’ll try to explain below. And you are correct. I do micromanage the game. I have posted a few times, apparently not here though, that I launch every plane, place every plane, fly every plane, fire every missile, drop every bomb, shoot every torpedo, place every sonobouy, and everything else, by hand. I never use a mission or patrol. The simple fact is that the computer AI does not do half as good a job at this as I can do. And you are correct that this can be a little overwhelming, and tedious, but I much prefer it this way, as opposed to losing many aircraft that I would not otherwise lose. I started a poll on HHQ asking how others play the game and the considerable majority of people seem to play mostly by hand.

Since I have had some difficulty in playing the game, I may not be fully versed in the effects of this self-defense behavior, but this is what I have noticed.

This automatic defensive behavior is less effective, less efficient, wasteful of munitions, and a considerably lesser defense than what I can achieve. And it interferes with me mounting a better defense.

This behavior is less effective than what I can do. If you have, say, a group of 10 missiles coming in at you, right on top of each other, appearing as one missile, my ships will automatically fire at them in a large group of missiles, two outgoing for each incoming, and achieve a hit rate of 4 to 8 strikes. Whereas I, using methods I have learned from experience, can fire only 10 missiles and achieve a hit rate of 6 to 10 on the incoming 10.

This makes the self-defense behavior less efficient and wasteful. In the end, it fires from 1.5 to 3 times as many missiles as I would, to achieve the same effect.

It fires large groups of missiles causing a ship to be ‘engaged’ unnecessarily, and less able to defend against strong threats coming at you. This is the opposite of the intended effect of the defensive behavior.

It fires at threats in an order that I would not do, and from ships that I would not use, leaving others open for attack. Again making it more difficult to defend.

It confuses the screen with large numbers of missiles that are difficult to determine what they are being fired at. This confusion also makes it difficult to determine what has not been fired at. Again making it more difficult to defend.

I have played a scenario where my task force begins very near many enemy units. The enemy began firing at me almost immediately. Ordinarily, this would have been only a moderately difficult situation had it not been for the interference of the automatic defensive behavior. Only through very difficult work and constant checking of what was happening, tediously trying to keep track of things, and some luck, was I able to defend myself without loss. I nearly lost two ships.

I must say that on two occasions the defense has saved a plane for me. But, on several occasions it has made defense of my task force more difficult. I would rather lose a plane or two, than lose any potion of my TF because of interference by the game itself. (That would really be bad. So far it hasn’t happened, though has come close.)

If I may, I would disagree with your opinion of how the game was designed to be played. I have played Harpoon AE for many years and some version before that. It seems to me that the game was designed to be played in a wide variety of ways. From those who wanted to play it using mostly missions and patrols, to those who wanted to do everything by hand, and anything in-between. With this flexibility of game play, Harpoon gained a large and loyal group of followers. Many people, perhaps most, play the game with weapons tight. This automatic defensive behavior comes very close to nullifying the weapons tight setting, and is a major change in the way the game is played. I can think of many-a-time when I have passed up firing on an enemy in order to save my weapons for a more important target, or, to use what I considered a better platform to fire from. This automatic firing of weapons has on a few occasions already, robbed me of my freedom of choice. And I am sure others, with better imaginations, can think of many other situations where they would not want this automatic firing of weapons to occur.

I understand from your post that the game is in transition, and I am quite sure there are many things to consider. And, I understand that not everyone can be pleased. Perhaps not even me. But, I hope you strongly consider the major change in the game when you even partially remove the weapons tight feature. Would it be reasonably easy to implement three settings? Weapons tight, automatic defense, and weapons free?

Even if the auto-defense could do as good a job, or better than I, I am not sure that I would want this. It might be nice to have the three options above and play with auto-defense when things were ‘to large’ to watch over easily, and then switch to weapons tight if things got hectic and I could do a better job. Or, to play with weapons tight, and switch to auto-defense if there were situations where it could be helpful. But if I had to make a choice, I much prefer the weapons tight to the current auto-defense. (Actually, having three choices sounds pretty good.)

I guess I should state here how important I think this matter is. For me, this auto-defense comes very close to making the game unplayable. There are several reasons for this. One is that the auto-defense plays inadequately enough that it will cause me to lose ships through no fault of my own, and causes the defense of my ships to be much more difficult in intense situations. Also, in some situations, it virtually takes over the game and I am reduced to being a spectator watching two computer opponents play against each other. It also in some situations, in small ways, takes away my freedom of choice in how to play the game.

For new Harpoon players, who have not played Harpoon differently, this may not be so bad. But for longtime players, many of us may not find this undefeatable feature enjoyable.

Boy this post is long. Sorry. I even left things out. And, if you are an official person, you have answered may question that this is now a ‘feature’ of the game and not a bug. I hope this post has given you some things to consider, and that you might try to ‘please’ those of us who play with weapons tight. Try the three settings choices.
Post #: 5
RE: How do I turn off automatic defensive behavior? - 5/30/2007 10:25:18 PM   


Posts: 165
Joined: 6/24/2005
Status: offline
Hello Flunkie,

I have taken a look at the issue you describe and have also talked to some people on the AGSI side. First of all it is correct that the behaviour now differs from previous versions. During the discussion with the AGSI guys I found out that the terms "weapons tight" and "weapons free" have a very specific meaning in the armed forces.

Weapons Hold
A weapon control order imposing a status whereby weapons systems may only be fired in self-defense or in response to a formal order.
Weapons Tight
In air defense, a weapon control order imposing a status whereby weapons systems may be fired only at targets recognized as hostile. (Err on the side of caution)
Weapons Free
A weapon control order imposing a status whereby weapons systems may be fired at any target not positively recognized as friendly.

As you can see "weapons tight" basically means fire if unit is positively identified as an enemy and even the "weapons hold" which is much stricter allows units to fire in self-defense. This means that the change actually brought the game behaviour closer to the formal definition of the ROE settings although "weapons tight" and "weapons free" are both still stricter in H3 than the real world.

Nevertheless, AGSI does realize, that manual control is important to many people, so I guess that some adjustments to the ROE settings will be made (My personal favorit would be implementing an additional "weapons hold" setting that gives full manual control). However, some other big issues like strike mission behaviour currently have top priority, so we'll see how far progress is and how much can be pushed into the next release.

Hope this clears up some of the reasoning behind all this.


(in reply to Flunkie)
Post #: 6
RE: How do I turn off automatic defensive behavior? - 5/31/2007 3:25:13 AM   
Jeff Gilbert


Posts: 67
Joined: 10/2/2005
Status: offline
Thanks for the update information.
Much appreciated ... I shall hold out my hopes for a "Weapons Super Tight" setting but understand completely that the developers have bigger fish to fry right now.


Jeff Gilbert
US Army [Ret]
Palm Harbor, Florida, USA

(in reply to jpkoester1)
Post #: 7
Page:   [1]
All Forums >> [Current Games From Matrix.] >> [Modern] >> Harpoon 3 - Advanced Naval Warfare >> How do I turn off automatic defensive behavior? Page: [1]
Jump to:

New Messages No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages Locked w/o New Messages
 Post New Thread
 Reply to Message
 Post New Poll
 Submit Vote
 Delete My Own Post
 Delete My Own Thread
 Rate Posts

Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI