Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
Moderators: wdolson, MOD_War-in-the-Pacific-Admirals-Edition
Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
By "zombie" here I mean enemy non-combat units such as HQ and base support that are left after a successful capture of their base. My most recent example: June 1944, the Chinese have just taken Hong Kong and all Japanese defenders were wiped out except for a Fleet HQ unit. After one day of rest, I attacked with 3 Chinese corps, AV of about 1100. The enemy unit was given a token AV of 1, presumably to avoid a division by zero. My units were fresh with very little if any disruption. And the grand result: about 30 enemy casualties, all disabled and not killed.
Based on earlier situations of this type, I expect similar results until the enemy supply is exhausted, when they will finally collapse quickly. What is going on that allows these units to hold out so long against overwhelming odds, with so few casualties?
Based on earlier situations of this type, I expect similar results until the enemy supply is exhausted, when they will finally collapse quickly. What is going on that allows these units to hold out so long against overwhelming odds, with so few casualties?
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
At this level of abstraction, I think they morph into a guerrilla unit. Disappear into a jungle, crawl into a cave... Think of your battle as a mop-up operation, and not pitched battle per se. You are really trying to FIND the enemy in the hex and they continually evade your troops. When you disable them, you simply scatter them... The enemy can endure well after the war ends,just like in RL.
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
BTW, If you really want to kill them, try bombing them with aircraft.
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
+1 . This sounds right, and HQ units are often the last units in a stack to have supply - I suppose because the programming makes HQs supply magnets so they get whatever trickles in. They also don't use any in actual combat because they have no weapons to shoot it off, so their supply lasts longer than combat units.ORIGINAL: Yaab
At this level of abstraction, I think they morph into a guerrilla unit. Disappear into a jungle, crawl into a cave... Think of your battle as a mop-up operation, and not pitched battle per se. You are really trying to FIND the enemy in the hex and they continually evade your troops. When you disable them, you simply scatter them... The enemy can endure well after the war ends,just like in RL.
No matter how bad a situation is, you can always make it worse. - Chris Hadfield : An Astronaut's Guide To Life On Earth
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
Bullwinkle and I have long thought there's something funny going on with HQ units in particular. They just don't die when they should and often stick around as units that just won't die - suffering minimal casualties, disruption, and morale loss in 200:1 odds attacks.
Seen it over and over.
Seen it over and over.
- HansBolter
- Posts: 7191
- Joined: Thu Jul 06, 2006 12:30 pm
- Location: United States
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
Some HQ units are very large and I believe every two support squads counts as a token combat squad so they take a very long time to kill off.
The non-combat squads given a token assault value must also have a very limited firepower value.
I agree with the general sentiment that there is something screwy in the way they are modeled.
With experience we all come to know what it takes to kill them off, lots and lots of time and attrition.
The non-combat squads given a token assault value must also have a very limited firepower value.
I agree with the general sentiment that there is something screwy in the way they are modeled.
With experience we all come to know what it takes to kill them off, lots and lots of time and attrition.
Hans
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
+1 ..caves, guerrilla fighting, etc.
Because of the example set Mitsuru Ushijima ?
Battle of Okinawa April 1 - June 21
The last remnants of Japanese resistance ended on June 21, although some Japanese continued hiding, including the future governor of Okinawa Prefecture, Masahide Ōta.[44] Ushijima and Chō committed suicide by seppuku in their command headquarters on Hill 89 in the closing hours of the battle. Colonel Yahara had asked Ushijima for permission to commit suicide, but the general refused his request, saying: "If you die there will be no one left who knows the truth about the battle of Okinawa. Bear the temporary shame but endure it. This is an order from your army Commander."[45] Yahara was the most senior officer to have survived the battle on the island, and he later authored a book titled The Battle for Okinawa. On August 15, 1945, Admiral Matome Ugaki was killed while part of a kamikaze raid on Iheyajima island. The official surrender ceremony was held on September 7,
Because of the example set Mitsuru Ushijima ?
Battle of Okinawa April 1 - June 21
The last remnants of Japanese resistance ended on June 21, although some Japanese continued hiding, including the future governor of Okinawa Prefecture, Masahide Ōta.[44] Ushijima and Chō committed suicide by seppuku in their command headquarters on Hill 89 in the closing hours of the battle. Colonel Yahara had asked Ushijima for permission to commit suicide, but the general refused his request, saying: "If you die there will be no one left who knows the truth about the battle of Okinawa. Bear the temporary shame but endure it. This is an order from your army Commander."[45] Yahara was the most senior officer to have survived the battle on the island, and he later authored a book titled The Battle for Okinawa. On August 15, 1945, Admiral Matome Ugaki was killed while part of a kamikaze raid on Iheyajima island. The official surrender ceremony was held on September 7,
A People that values its privileges above it's principles will soon loose both. Dwight D Eisenhower.
-
- Posts: 2818
- Joined: Sat Sep 19, 2009 6:13 am
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
Guerilla warfare does not explain why exactly HQs are so adept at it, and not the usual rank and file infantry
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
The guys get into the HQ by being good at avoiding combat! [:D]ORIGINAL: GetAssista
Guerilla warfare does not explain why exactly HQs are so adept at it, and not the usual rank and file infantry
No matter how bad a situation is, you can always make it worse. - Chris Hadfield : An Astronaut's Guide To Life On Earth
-
- Posts: 1510
- Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2016 3:40 am
- Location: Zichron Yaaqov, Israel; Before, Treviso, Italy
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
A hex symbolizing-simulating a 40x 40 miles. Go and find those 1200 or less troops who do not seek combat. On the contrary: the game is too much generous in enabling 100% of time contact and direct combat between units in a hex, even if a company against another one...
War In the East obviated to some, or many, of these shortcomings.
War In the East obviated to some, or many, of these shortcomings.
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
When suffering attacks with high odds against them, Japanese units will make a check to banzai charge rather than surrender. I think what happens with Japanese HQ units is that they pass the check to banzai rather than surrender (because of generally high leadership), but they are incapable of making a banzai attack because they have 0 AV. This results in nothing happening, and the unit continues in existence rather than being destroyed as any unit with AV would. This is merely a guess, however, as to why Japanese HQs are so difficult to destroy.
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
Did you tried a shock attack?
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
ORIGINAL: Dili
Did you tried a shock attack?
Not yet, in this particular instance: I've only had time for the one deliberate attack mentioned at the beginning.
Thanks for all the comments. The suggestion that the enemy unit disperses into a guerilla role might make sense in some cases, but it's harder to believe for an HQ unit. Also it would be a lot more plausible in Japanese home territory, as Okinawa, as opposed to Hong Kong where I am sure that everyone hated them and there was no safe refuge anywhere.
At Hong Kong, this isn't really a problem. My victorious army needs some downtime for R+R, and this low intensity fight for a little while won't hurt anything. In other places, an enemy holdout will block rail movement and supply flow. In still others, such as small islands, it makes it take longer to pull out units and end overstacking.
- Chickenboy
- Posts: 24520
- Joined: Fri Jun 28, 2002 11:30 pm
- Location: San Antonio, TX
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
ORIGINAL: jwolf
By "zombie" here I mean enemy non-combat units such as HQ and base support that are left after a successful capture of their base. My most recent example: June 1944, the Chinese have just taken Hong Kong and all Japanese defenders were wiped out except for a Fleet HQ unit. After one day of rest, I attacked with 3 Chinese corps, AV of about 1100. The enemy unit was given a token AV of 1, presumably to avoid a division by zero. My units were fresh with very little if any disruption. And the grand result: about 30 enemy casualties, all disabled and not killed.
Based on earlier situations of this type, I expect similar results until the enemy supply is exhausted, when they will finally collapse quickly. What is going on that allows these units to hold out so long against overwhelming odds, with so few casualties?
jwolf:
Are you playing PBEM or against the AI? Against the latter-particularly on 'hard' or 'very hard' settings, all units derive some supply regardless of LOS control and cannot effectively be attritioned by the traditional "starve 'em out" approach.
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
It is AI, and hard difficulty. I don't know just how much "bonus supply" trapped AI units get, but in practice they do get supply combat penalties after a while. So maybe not totally out of supply, but not nearly enough to stay viable as a fighting unit.
- Chickenboy
- Posts: 24520
- Joined: Fri Jun 28, 2002 11:30 pm
- Location: San Antonio, TX
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
ORIGINAL: jwolf
It is AI, and hard difficulty. I don't know just how much "bonus supply" trapped AI units get, but in practice they do get supply combat penalties after a while. So maybe not totally out of supply, but not nearly enough to stay viable as a fighting unit.
Yes, something like that. I think this may explain the majority of what you are seeing.
-
- Posts: 2818
- Joined: Sat Sep 19, 2009 6:13 am
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
You can attrition them on 'hard' just fine, they do not get supply out of thin air. Although attrition in this case means fighting/bombing because they do not die from hunger alone.ORIGINAL: Chickenboy
Are you playing PBEM or against the AI? Against the latter-particularly on 'hard' or 'very hard' settings, all units derive some supply regardless of LOS control and cannot effectively be attritioned by the traditional "starve 'em out" approach.
'very hard' is another matter.
- LargeSlowTarget
- Posts: 4801
- Joined: Sat Sep 23, 2000 8:00 am
- Location: Hessen, Germany - now living in France
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
ORIGINAL: BBfanboy
The guys get into the HQ by being good at avoiding combat! [:D]ORIGINAL: GetAssista
Guerilla warfare does not explain why exactly HQs are so adept at it, and not the usual rank and file infantry
REMF = Roving Evasion Main Force
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
A shock attack will give you the same results, just with larger odds.
I'll be shocked if you kill more than 100 of them if you killed 39 in your last DA with 200:1 odds.
I'll be shocked if you kill more than 100 of them if you killed 39 in your last DA with 200:1 odds.
RE: Why are zombie units so hard to kill?
That would be nice to know