My 2 cents worth
Give you an idea of my own movie preferences
Was in middle school when Original "New Hope" came out, was perfect age/target audience, Star Wars geek ever since. (Luke as a teen, Obi Wan old) Loved New Hope and Empire Strikes back, loved 1st half of Return of the Jedi, but very disappointed with Ewok. Really, 3 foot teddy bears with sticks beating Storm Troopers?? Now if Endor had bunch of angry Wookies with sticks and rocks smashing storm troopers, that would be great.
Really disliked prequels, 1st one (Ankin as a child). Lots of reasons; Jar Jar force power measured by a blood test, Jedi are nonchalant about slavery, only saving grace was fight with Darth Maul, Ewan McGregor and Liam Neson. 2nd prequel, Anikin is whining teen, really, really bad acting, overemphasis on bad CGI. Did like the general idea of how/why he starts to turn and Ewan MCGregor did a good job with Obi Wan. 3rd one is watchable for me, still really bad acting by Anikin, but Obi Wan did great and plot was ok.
Loved Rogue One, really well done
Really enjoyed The Force Awakens, liked the new characters and story line. Only problem I had was the whole "Let's build another Death Star". The operational plans of the Empire, or Last Order must be from the the same staff that buys Storm Trooper Armor. Admiral, our armor can't even stop sticks from 3 foot teddy bears and do you know what happened to the 1st two Death Stars?
SPOILERS for Last Jedi
Mixed feelings on it. Like the graphics and return to some of the big space battles. Liked almost all of the characters and the overall direction of the plot and the length of the move. Also enjoyed teasing of Kylo turning good, or at least not totally bad. Like the fight with Kylo, Rey and guards.
Dislikes, Luke as the grumpy old hermit who tries to kill his nephew in his sleep. Luke as a dairy farmer was really really bad, I am ok with his death but wish he would have been more of the philosophical, mentor role for Ray, teaching her the force. Show him as conflicted/reluctant to teach her, worried about his own pull toward dark side and his experience teaching Kylo. He just came across as the "kids, get off my lawn" guy.
Just hoping they bring back Wedge Antilles for the last move