NOT JUST Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post descriptions of your brilliant victories and unfortunate defeats here.

Moderators: wdolson, MOD_War-in-the-Pacific-Admirals-Edition

Post Reply
User avatar
FDRLincoln
Posts: 744
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 3:10 pm
Location: Lawrence, KS
Contact:

NOT JUST Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by FDRLincoln »

Scenario Two, PDU on, typical house rules...

The main focus of this AAR will be submarine warfare, which both contestants are big fans of. We've played two turns so far.

DECEMBER 7 JAPAN:

None of my Imperial submarines had any success on Day One. Four midget subs were lost attempting to penetrate Pearl Harbor. None of my other submarines had any contacts.

DECEMBER 7 ALLIES:

A Dutch submarine torpedoed and sank an AK filled with troops heading towards Malaya. OUCH!

DECEMBER 8 JAPAN:

Submarine I-21 torpedoed an American four-stack destroyer, reportedly USS McFarland, east of Hawaii. The destroyer was heavily damaged by two torpedoes but so far there is no confirmation of sinking.

DECEMBER 8 ALLIES:

No contacts.

I will keep a running total of tonnage in subsequent posts.
Fear God and Dread Nought
User avatar
FDRLincoln
Posts: 744
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 3:10 pm
Location: Lawrence, KS
Contact:

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by FDRLincoln »

December 9th Allies: 
 
US Submarine S-39 attempted to torpedo a Japanese light cruiser south of the Phillipines. The torpedoes missed and S-39 was driven off by the escorts.

December 9th Japan:

None of my submarines made contact with Allied forces.

TONNAGE SUNK:
A Dutch submarine sank AK Johore Maru on December 7th, 6400 tons.
Fear God and Dread Nought
User avatar
FDRLincoln
Posts: 744
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 3:10 pm
Location: Lawrence, KS
Contact:

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by FDRLincoln »

December 10 Japan: No submarines made contact with Allied forces.
December 10 Allies: Submarine S-37 attempted to attack a convoy near Formosa but was driven under by the escorts
 
Quiet thus far
Fear God and Dread Nought
User avatar
FDRLincoln
Posts: 744
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 3:10 pm
Location: Lawrence, KS
Contact:

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by FDRLincoln »

Is there any interest in this AAR among submarine fans?
Fear God and Dread Nought
User avatar
FDRLincoln
Posts: 744
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 3:10 pm
Location: Lawrence, KS
Contact:

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by FDRLincoln »

Finally, something interesting

December 11 Japan: Responding to reports of American carriers in the area, submarine RO-64 took up patrol station near Tarawa to defend the landing at that atoll. RO-64 encountered USS Lexington at night and reported two torpedo hits before being driven down by the escorts which conducted an ineffective depth charge attack. Condition of Lexington is unknown, but she did launch a daytime airstrike against some transports, so she can't be too badly hurt. Still, it was nice to finally see a contact. Too bad it was one of the oldest ROs instead of a modern I-boat.

December 11 Allies: Dutch submarine KXV attempted to interfere with landings at Miri but was driven off by the ASW screen. Similarly, US submarine S-41 attempted to attack a convoy near Formosa but was caught on approach and depth-charged by escorting DDs. Neither submarine appeared to suffer substantial damage but were suppressed.
Fear God and Dread Nought
User avatar
FDRLincoln
Posts: 744
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 3:10 pm
Location: Lawrence, KS
Contact:

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by FDRLincoln »

Image
Fear God and Dread Nought
User avatar
Ossian
Posts: 100
Joined: Thu Jul 07, 2005 7:38 pm

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by Ossian »

Is there any interest in this AAR among submarine fans?


Yup, there sure is! In fact, I'm doing my own AAR as the Japanese over at SubSim.com at the moment so I'm very interested in how this develops and how you use your boats. We're only playing the Guadalcanal scenario but my oppo has creamed my sub fleet pretty much and it' not even the new year yet.

Two questions, because it's an area that tends to get skirted over a bit in other AARs: what's your basic strategy for sub ops at the moment (IE, are you focusing them anywhere? Around Pearl, the WC, Malay and the DEI? and have you changed many of the skippers yet? with the Allies I feel you have to change a large number of them in the first few months for more aggressive skippers to maximize the few chances you get (especially when you add in the crappy Mk.14s to the mix.)

I think I'm going to enjoy this! [:)]
User avatar
FDRLincoln
Posts: 744
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 3:10 pm
Location: Lawrence, KS
Contact:

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by FDRLincoln »

Well, I am Japan in a PBEM game. I don't know if my opponent is reading this or not, but I won't give anything away he doesn't know or suspect or can read by Ultra decrypts, lol. 

I have not made contact with a single a US Fleet Boat, so I don't know what he's doing with them. All I have seen are S-boats and Dutch subs. My ASW philosophy revolves around patrols with smaller craft around harbors and choke points, and I try to give every important convoy at least a minimal escort, although that won't always be possible. I like lots of ASW air. Even if they can't sink something, if they spot it it helps.

My own submarines were deployed per standard at the beginning of the game: a whole bunch of them around Hawaii, and some around Malaya. I still have subs prowling around Hawaii, but some have been recalled to their bases for refuelling and then redeployment to new patrol stations. The subs around Malaya and the western DEI area are (more or less) scouting around for RN or Dutch warships. I also like to use subs to provide some "underwater escort" of my invasion forces. RO-64 was doing this around Tarawa and it paid off. Once the initial set of invasions is complete, the longer range boats will be deployed against Allied commerce lanes and shorter-range boats on defensive patrols. I hope to pick off some warships of course, especially early when allied ASW is less effective.

I haven't changed any captains yet.
Fear God and Dread Nought
User avatar
FDRLincoln
Posts: 744
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 3:10 pm
Location: Lawrence, KS
Contact:

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by FDRLincoln »

How I use the submarine arm also depends on what my overall strategy for entire game is. I'm going to make sure my opponent isn't reading this first before revealing my overall grand strategy.
Fear God and Dread Nought
User avatar
FDRLincoln
Posts: 744
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 3:10 pm
Location: Lawrence, KS
Contact:

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by FDRLincoln »

My opponent confirms that he had to scuttle USS McFarland.
Fear God and Dread Nought
User avatar
FDRLincoln
Posts: 744
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 3:10 pm
Location: Lawrence, KS
Contact:

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by FDRLincoln »

My opponent has agreed to stay out of this AAR.

While I don't have the time for a full-fledged classic AAR, I will keep this up-to-date with major happenings and my strategic plans, with a focus on the undersea war.

It is Scenario 2, PDU on, December 7 surprise, non-historical first turn, US torpedoes are BAD, Allied damage control is good.

For the most part, I left things historical for the initial attacks. The Pearl Harbor strike resulted in the sinking of Arizona and Tennessee, plus substantial damage to four other battleships although my opponent says they will all survive. A great deal of his air force was destroyed on the ground and first day losses for Japan were very small, so I stuck around for a second day. Alas, this didn't go well at all: Kaga's attack flew, but the other carriers failed to launch their planes on the second day. I think weather may have been involved. He got 20 P-40s up, and while my A6Ms shot five of them down, I ended up losing 12 Vals without doing any damage. I left after that.

KB moved up north, refuelled from the AO group, and is now swinging back down towards Truk to provide air cover for subsequent offensives and to see if I can trap his carriers somewhere.

The current day is December 12th. Vigan, Appari, and Legaspi have fallen, and San Fernando should fall tomorrow. He has been aggressive about defending the Phillipines and has by my count about 40 P-40Bs and Es present. My A6M sweeps are giving me air superiority but not air supremacy at this point. I'm bombing his airfields, switching between Clark and Manila to try and keep him guessing, since he's using both bases. My land combat units have faced little opposition so far, as he is pulling everything back towards the central core as quickly as possible. I don't know yet if he will make his stand at Bataan or Manila. His land forces seem evenly divided so far between those locations and Clark.

Davao will be invaded as soon as the cruiser squadron to cover the landing has been refueled.

I intend to make China a major theatre of operations since the whole point of the war is to conquer China! Hong Kong is under seige. Once Hong Kong falls I will get more aggressive here, but I want that port first. I've conducted small scale bombing attacks in various locations, and have begun paying the PP to pull some of the forces facing the Soviet Union down south. I won't go past the Soviet activition limit of course.

In the DEI, Miri has fallen, and Brunei will be hit tomorrow. I don't know where Force Z is, but Bettys and Nells have sunk some shipping escaping the Phillipines, including AV Langley. I have strong surface combat units prowling this area and covering convoys in case he tries to sneak a strike in. One of my cruiser squadrons fell in with a convoy of Phillipine shipping and sank four AKs. I would really rather neutralize Force Z before going further south than Miri, but if I don't find them soon I will get things moving. I have been studying the map closely and have my invasions of Java and Sumatra planned out, with the allocated units planning. I hope to seize them in early January.

Malaya is going slowly so far as my amphibious forces are busy unloading at the usual places. He seems to be conducting a defense in depth and isn't withdrawing everything towards Singapore as far as I can tell. I've been conducting daily bombing raids and sweeps here. Nates and Oscars...very good dogfighters, but the lack of firepower is telling. I get a lot of damaged Buffalos in these combats, but not a lot of shootdowns.

Snipping the Burma Road is one of my major goals and forces led by the Imperial Guard and associated armor are moving towards the border. He had AVG at Tavoy and this resulted in a big dogfight with some A6M units. I got the better of it.

So far, my worst losses are an AK torpedoed by a Dutch sub on the way to Malaya, and a destroyer (I don't have the name at my fingertips) that was knocked out by the USS Louisville attempting to intervene at Tarawa. As mentioned earlier, he also has Lexington in the vicinity.

I have various invasions on the way to locations in the Solomons, but he is being very aggressive with cruiser and carrier strikes to keep me off balance. I am reluctant to push too far until KB is in the area. I also have my main BB line heading towards Truk to help support operations as needed. This can swing south if I think his surface forces are going to interfere in the Solomons, or it can swing west to help support the invasions planned for the Celebes and eastern Borneo.
Fear God and Dread Nought
User avatar
FDRLincoln
Posts: 744
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 3:10 pm
Location: Lawrence, KS
Contact:

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by FDRLincoln »

I know a lot of Japanese players strike northern Australia or make a deep drive into India. Raiding Australia makes sense to me, but actually invading it...that isn't something in intend to do. I might change my mind depending on how things develop, but I am more likely to send KB out occasionally to assault convoys heading to/from Oz.

I don't really want to Death Star him with KB...that's no fun...but I'm not going to let KB die in penny packets, either.

I forgot to mention that the Wake Invasion, conducted with the historical forces, had the historical result: I got my ass handed to me. A second, stronger force is being prepared. Perhaps...maybe I can tempt him into trying to reinforce Wake and cover it with his carriers? Hmm.
Fear God and Dread Nought
User avatar
FDRLincoln
Posts: 744
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 3:10 pm
Location: Lawrence, KS
Contact:

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by FDRLincoln »

He has used his naval forces in the Phillipines aggressively. I wiped out a squadron of four old destroyers that tried to stop the landings at Vigan at no loss to myself. He tried to sneak in PT boats the next day. Somehow they got past the patrolling cruisers, but the landing beaches were covered by minesweeper and ASW units that got into a surface battle with the PTs, sinking two.
Fear God and Dread Nought
User avatar
EUBanana
Posts: 4255
Joined: Tue Sep 30, 2003 3:48 pm
Location: Little England
Contact:

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by EUBanana »

ORIGINAL: FDRLincoln

Is there any interest in this AAR among submarine fans?

Sure. I always like the sub war too. I tend to do a report every month or so just focused on subs.

You probably wanna include some other stuff as well though, it's not like subs worked in a vacuum after all..
Image
User avatar
FDRLincoln
Posts: 744
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 3:10 pm
Location: Lawrence, KS
Contact:

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by FDRLincoln »

December 12 Japan: RO-64 takes another shot at Lexington near Tarawa but misses, driven under by escorts. No damage from depth charging. Opponent informs me that Lexington was only dinged by yesterday's attack. Damn. RO-64's captain seems very aggressive, and when he gets back to port he will be moved up to a better sub.

I-158 takes a shot at HMS Vendetta near Singapore, but all three torpedoes miss. I-153 tries to follow up, misses with her attack, and is given a tough depth-charging by British destroyers, resulting in 20 floatation damage. She is on her way back to Saigon for repairs.

December 12 Allies: S-37 tries to attack a convoy near Formosa but is depth-charged by the ASW screen without getting a shot off. 

OTHER ITEMS: San Fernando falls. Nauru Island falls. More reinforcements land at Vigan and Appari and are heading south.

Four heavy cruisers and six destroyers arrive at Truk. They will begin covering operations for invasions in this area. 

An allied cruiser task force led by Houston, Boise, and Marblehead ambushes a supply convoy unloading at Miri. Light cruiser Isuzu and a couple of patrol boats attempt to intervene but are destroyed. I lose five xAKs, but fortunately the landing force was already ashore. The enemy force expended a great deal of ammunition. Two battlecruisers, five heavy cruisers, two light cruisers, and ten destroyers are heading in this direction to try and trap the Americans. Note that Force Z is still unaccounted for, and I suspect there could be a trap afoot.  

Baby KB and a pair of heavy cruisers found and slaughtered escaping merchant ships from the Phillipines. Main KB has refuelled from the big AO group and is proceeding towards Truk, looking for Enterprise which is expected to be somewhere in the Wake Island area.
Fear God and Dread Nought
User avatar
FDRLincoln
Posts: 744
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 3:10 pm
Location: Lawrence, KS
Contact:

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by FDRLincoln »

December 13 Japan: RO-64 makes another attempt at the Lexington task force and is once again driven off by destroyers but undamaged. I-8 attempted to torpedo a freighter near Hawaii, missed, and got depth-charged by escorts but was undamaged.
 
Lexington pounded the Nauhru Island invasion force but the troops got ashore. I have six submarines in the area but so far only RO-64 has tried to attack.

December 13 Allies: Dutch submarine KXI tried to get hit a convoy near Patani but was attacked by escorts and didn't get a shot off. Combat screen reports three DC hits but I think she got away.

Where are his US fleet subs? I haven't seen a single one. I know the torpedoes are bad, but you'd think they would be useful for scouting around, and sometimes the torps do hit. I think this is a mistake on his part.
Fear God and Dread Nought
User avatar
Crackaces
Posts: 3858
Joined: Sat Jul 09, 2011 3:39 pm

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by Crackaces »

Where are his US fleet subs? I haven't seen a single one. I know the torpedoes are bad, but you'd think they would be useful for scouting around, and sometimes the torps do hit. I think this is a mistake on his part.

It is a mistake in my opinion. I had 5 xAK's full of stuff sunk by USN SS platforms between the 8-12 Dec 41. Yes the odds are quite low per torp P(.20) but it forces the IJN to escort precious cargo. By Sept 42 I have over 50 merchants and 2 CL's sunk by the USN. A CV spent 3 months in the pen from a slug delvered by the USN SS Sargo [;)]

Also, they intercept radio traffic in the lanes etc ..

"What gets us into trouble is not what we don't know. It's what we know for sure that just ain't so"
User avatar
FDRLincoln
Posts: 744
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 3:10 pm
Location: Lawrence, KS
Contact:

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by FDRLincoln »

December 14 Japan: Submarine I-8 is playing cat-and-mouse with an ASW detachment near Hawaii. She fired two torpedoes at USS Alwyn but missed. No damage from DCs. Four other long-range submarines are approaching West Coast patrol stations. Submarines with less endurance are heading back to Kwajalein for refuelling, then will deploy to interdict his communications with Australia.

December 14 Allies: Dutch submarine KXIII was DCd near Saigon. I don't think she took any serious damage. Other allied subs have been spotted near Truk and Saipan.

Overall Situation: A quiet turn in the air and sea, not so on land. A tank unit mauled a raw Chinese corps in open ground. I am closing in on the Manila and Clark from multiple directions. It looks like he will make his stand at Clark if my recon is remotely accurate. I'm still seeing evidence of 40-50 P40s in the Phillipines but they haven't flow in several days.
Fear God and Dread Nought
User avatar
FDRLincoln
Posts: 744
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 3:10 pm
Location: Lawrence, KS
Contact:

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by FDRLincoln »

It appears that both Lexington and Enterprise are hanging around the Eastern Solomons looking for stuff to ambush. I have some transports ready at Truk with various invasion forces that were ready to head south, but with his carriers in the area I'm holding back until KB arrives. I have six submarines being vectored into his area looking for his carriers.

My main battle fleet centered around Nagato and Mutso was preparing for a sweep through the Celebes and eastern Borneo area to clear the area of any ABDA forces attempting to interfere with invasions that I was planning to launch in the next turn. However, the timetable has been altered a bit: Kongo and Haruna collided in a night battle with some PT boats. Both battlecruisers are damaged and have to head back to Cam Ran Bay for repairs. I now have to reorganize my Western Borneo fleet before moving to hit Palembang and associated smaller bases.

Not knowing where Force Z is, I am reluctant to launch the invasions of Palembang and southwest Borneo without Kongo and Haruna. Am I being too cautious?
Fear God and Dread Nought
User avatar
FDRLincoln
Posts: 744
Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 3:10 pm
Location: Lawrence, KS
Contact:

RE: Submarines in the Pacific: FDRLincoln (Japan) vs. Bakerman (Allies)

Post by FDRLincoln »

December 15 Japan: I-173 sticks three torpedoes into the side of AP Hugh L. Scott near Hawaii. Will she make it back to Pearl? I don't know. I didn't get any message about troops so I'm assuming she was empty.

December 15 Allies: Dutch boat KXI sticks one torpedo into AK Teihoken Maru near Malaya. This ship had troops on it but made it one hex into port and is unloading. Lucky.

Fear God and Dread Nought
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”