CoS, that was good. I actually still have it.
SC2, CEAW, nice design, layout, But I hate naval systems like that. If you ever played (board game) World in Flames that has the best naval system as a balance for this scale I have ever seen. (board game) ETO-PTO had all the ships individually, DDs, CAs, CVEs, DEs, on a smaller scale but it was an el-destructo fest in the ocean. Their naval combat system was long tedious and irraticating. In 3 months a whole navy could be wiped out. As for PC games SC2 is my choise even though CEAW looks better if I play the PC. Heads up probably CEAW. I think SC2 is more flexible and you can better individualize units without much hassle. CEAW has oil and manpower.
My god I think I just rambled on.