Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Fury Games has now signed with Matrix Games, and we are working together on the next Strategic Command. Will use the Slitherine PBEM++ server for asynchronous multi-player.

Moderators: MOD_Strategic_Command_3, Fury Software

Post Reply
User avatar
Bylandt11
Posts: 85
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 5:01 pm

Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by Bylandt11 »

I read about people rushing units west to beat France and then east again to start an early offensive against the USSR (spring 1941)

But is that really a good idea? In 1 year Germany can have a FAR stronger force to attack (in spring 1942). Doesn't attacking early trigger a lot of events and mechanisms early that also work in the allies' advantage?
User avatar
sPzAbt653
Posts: 9936
Joined: Thu May 03, 2007 7:11 am
Location: east coast, usa

RE: Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by sPzAbt653 »

Soviets will attack you in 1941 anyway.
User avatar
OxfordGuy3
Posts: 1179
Joined: Sun Jul 01, 2012 4:44 pm
Location: Oxford, United Kingdom

RE: Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by OxfordGuy3 »

When is the earliest possible date for a clear weather turn in Russia in 1941? You really don't want to be attacking before then, would also not be ideal if the following turn ends up not being clear...
"The object of war is not to die for your country, but to make the other bastard die for his" - George S. Patton
User avatar
Boonierat1972
Posts: 86
Joined: Thu Nov 17, 2016 2:29 pm
Location: France
Contact:

RE: Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by Boonierat1972 »

You can invest in diplomacy to delay their entry but nobody wants to pay 125 MPPs a chit.
Stéphane Moutin-Luyat
Vietnam Combat Operations
Beruldsen
Posts: 174
Joined: Tue Feb 15, 2011 11:52 am

RE: Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by Beruldsen »

With any luck you can have clear skies in the first week/turn in April '41. I prefer to attack early with the most ready forces in the north ... followed by Central ... and then South ... delaying the Central and South by at least a turn.
User avatar
OxfordGuy3
Posts: 1179
Joined: Sun Jul 01, 2012 4:44 pm
Location: Oxford, United Kingdom

RE: Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by OxfordGuy3 »

ORIGINAL: Arne Beruldsen

With any luck you can have clear skies in the first week/turn in April '41. I prefer to attack early with the most ready forces in the north ... followed by Central ... and then South ... delaying the Central and South by at least a turn.

Why delay attacking with Central and South?
"The object of war is not to die for your country, but to make the other bastard die for his" - George S. Patton
User avatar
churruca
Posts: 38
Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2002 9:12 pm
Location: Spain-Madrid
Contact:

RE: Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by churruca »

In my game I was ready to attack but the USSR attacked me on April '41 (well, in fact they only declared war).
As I have detailed in other post, right now I'm playing Oct '42 with Leningrad in my hands, at the gates of Voroneth and fighting for Moscow for almost eight months.
It seems that the russians are a little bit weak right now, so I think that Moscow should fall by '43 maybe ending the war.
"Recuerdo cuando el Sol no se ponía en nuestro imperio!"
bo
Posts: 4175
Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2009 9:52 pm

RE: Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by bo »

I was having all kind of problems with Russia by attacking them in June, so I am going after them in May. I personally feel it is better to have beefed up units than a lot of units early on, but that is just me.

Learned one important thing in attacking Russian troops, move fast and keep your HQ's with your lead elements, and always upgrade the HQ's, expensive but it must be done. Capture every city you can or bypass them if they are well dug in. I learned about supply the hard way, with low supply you might as well do nothing, supply is the key to the game IMO.

Bo
User avatar
OxfordGuy3
Posts: 1179
Joined: Sun Jul 01, 2012 4:44 pm
Location: Oxford, United Kingdom

RE: Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by OxfordGuy3 »

ORIGINAL: bo

I was having all kind of problems with Russia by attacking them in June, so I am going after them in May. I personally feel it is better to have beefed up units than a lot of units early on, but that is just me.

Learned one important thing in attacking Russian troops, move fast and keep your HQ's with your lead elements, and always upgrade the HQ's, expensive but it must be done. Capture every city you can or bypass them if they are well dug in. I learned about supply the hard way, with low supply you might as well do nothing, supply is the key to the game IMO.

Bo

Definitely, BTW is interesting to see how having mutliple HQs in a small area affects supply, makes the Italians much more effective in Egypt if you support them with two HQs quite close together
"The object of war is not to die for your country, but to make the other bastard die for his" - George S. Patton
Yogol
Posts: 219
Joined: Wed Nov 30, 2016 9:28 am

RE: Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by Yogol »

HQs are very important.

In Russia, each of my forces (north, central & south) have 2 HQs that are only 1 or 2 hexes from each other and one of the HQs is always near a city. This will ensure that one of the HQs give 8 supply and the other : one of the HQs will give 8 supply and the other will give 10 supply.

This gives a better supply than sending one HQ to the front, because that HQ will only give 8 supply (instead of 10). And if it's not near a city, it only gives 5 supply, which pretty much kills your front units.


And to answer the OP...
In my current game, on the highest difficulty level, I attacked Russia as late as possible (in October 1941, I couldn't wait any longer because they were above 90%).

By that time, Germany occupied...
- Poland
- Luxemburg
- Netherlands
- Belgium
- France
- Vichy France
- Swiss (!)
- Sweden (!!)
- Yugoslavia
- Greece
- Algiers
- Tunis

- Bulgaria, Hungary* & Romania joined Axis.
- Spain joined Axis
- Portugal & Gibraltar were taken by the Spanish.
- Malta was taken by the German.


Some German troops were still near Greece and in Sweden when I attacked USSR, they didn't make it back in time to the Russian border.
But I couldn't wait anymore, because the % of USSR goes up FAST in those months, even when you keep only 4 troops "near" Warsau.


But... this is NOT the way to go on the highest difficulty level.
Because if you wait so long, Russia has so many troops (all with +2 experience) that you can not get to Moscow AND Leningrad AND Stalingrad: he has simply too many troops by then that are too strong. That +2 experience really, really hurts.

I did the same on normal difficulty level and that went very well, because without the +2 experience, you can kill up to 10 Russian troops per turn.
But with the +2 experience, every army in a city takes forever to kill :(


* Hungary added after the after originally post, cause I forgot about it. Sorry to all Hungarians!
User avatar
OxfordGuy3
Posts: 1179
Joined: Sun Jul 01, 2012 4:44 pm
Location: Oxford, United Kingdom

RE: Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by OxfordGuy3 »

This is why I send both Italian HQs to Africa, makes a big difference until Rommel arrives
"The object of war is not to die for your country, but to make the other bastard die for his" - George S. Patton
User avatar
OxfordGuy3
Posts: 1179
Joined: Sun Jul 01, 2012 4:44 pm
Location: Oxford, United Kingdom

RE: Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by OxfordGuy3 »

ORIGINAL: Yogol

HQs are very important.

In Russia, each of my forces (north, central & south) have 2 HQs that are only 1 or 2 hexes from each other and one of the HQs is always near a city. This will ensure that one of the HQs give 8 supply and the other : one of the HQs will give 8 supply and the other will give 10 supply.

This gives a better supply than sending one HQ to the front, because that HQ will only give 8 supply (instead of 10). And if it's not near a city, it only gives 5 supply, which pretty much kills your front units.


And to answer the OP...
In my current game, on the highest difficulty level, I attacked Russia as late as possible (in October 1941, I couldn't wait any longer because they were above 90%).

By that time, Germany occupied...
- Poland
- Luxemburg
- Netherlands
- Belgium
- France
- Vichy France
- Swiss (!)
- Sweden (!!)
- Yugoslavia
- Greece
- Algiers
- Tunis

- Bulgaria & Romania joined Axis.
- Spain joined Axis
- Portugal & Gibraltar were taken by the Spanish.
- Malta was taken by the German.


Some German troops were still near Greece and in Sweden when I attacked USSR, they didn't make it back in time to the Russian border.
But I couldn't wait anymore, because the % of USSR goes up FAST in those months, even when you keep only 4 troops "near" Warsau.


But... this is NOT the way to go on the highest difficulty level.
Because if you wait so long, Russia has so many troops (all with +2 experience) that you can not get to Moscow AND Leningrad AND Stalingrad: he has simply too many troops by then that are too strong. That +2 experience really, really hurts.

I did the same on normal difficulty level and that went very well, because without the +2 experience, you can kill up to 10 Russian troops per turn.
But with the +2 experience, every army in a city takes forever to kill :(


Did attacking all those countries (especially. Switzerland) make the USA enter the war much earlier, though? How are you doing in Libya/Egypt?
"The object of war is not to die for your country, but to make the other bastard die for his" - George S. Patton
User avatar
OxfordGuy3
Posts: 1179
Joined: Sun Jul 01, 2012 4:44 pm
Location: Oxford, United Kingdom

RE: Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by OxfordGuy3 »

What about Hungary? Did they join the axis?
"The object of war is not to die for your country, but to make the other bastard die for his" - George S. Patton
CapitaineHaddock
Posts: 39
Joined: Mon Oct 31, 2016 10:57 am

RE: Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by CapitaineHaddock »

Take out France in june 1940, transport all your forces to the East and attack the USSR in July 1940. just bare minimum Research in tanks and infantry, sell all other chits and buy as many tanks and mech as possible. By sept. 41 I have all three Soviet Victory Cities and the Red Army is broken (normal difficulty settings).

Now I've started as Allies and follow the opposite strategy With the UK. Sell all excess chits, research bare minimum (armored warfare!), transport army and HQ from Egypt and buy units (tanks, art, corps...) for all it's worth. I'm now in late July 40 and the front seems to be holding for the moment being. Will be interesting to see how it Works out in the end.

It's high time for multiplayer!
johnvmcnichols1973
Posts: 15
Joined: Tue Jan 12, 2010 11:47 am

RE: Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by johnvmcnichols1973 »

Even with normal settings I had a hard time with the normal version of events, i.e Poland, then attack france, then turn against Soviets while holding UK in check and overrunning Africa. Problem was always Soviet tech upgrades. I could never get deep enough into Russia before the odds turned against me. I could usually overrun Africa, but in the end it was too lengthy and the US would start invading in west africa or hit me as early as 43 in France. I tried a different approach:

After France falls, which I did early, I invaded UK. Took an extra year due to weather!! Who knew it rained so much in the channel :) However, Soviets declared war in late 42 and although I was forced to invade then with few units, I managed to hold the line in the east while taking the UK. It is now late 45, I have broken through on the east front and pushing Soviets back. I have all of Africa and am battling through Persia into South USSR. Still waiting on Turkey to join though..:( Interesting as UK moved govt to Canada, so they did not surrender. Couple Ai issues though:

US continues to send large Amphibious formations to UK with no escorts!! I have sunk two large groups of US invasion troops and continue to destroy piecemeal US and UK ships as they approach UK and France. This has given me time to build a huge naval fleet of German, Italian, Spanish and Swedish ships. Had the US, UK and Canadian fleets been smarter, they could have used the tech advantage in naval warfare and blew me out of the water earlier. Paving the way for invasions all along my west frontier. Oh well, multiplayer will erase that issue :)

Yogol
Posts: 219
Joined: Wed Nov 30, 2016 9:28 am

RE: Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by Yogol »

ORIGINAL: oxford_guy

Did attacking all those countries (especially. Switzerland) make the USA enter the war much earlier, though? How are you doing in Libya/Egypt?


Yes, the US enter earlier.

But the war isn't won in the west, it's won (or lost) in the east.

Besides... once you have Gibraltar and can move the entire Italian fleet west, you can pretty much keep the USA "out of the war" by patrolling their coasts with your Italian fleet and some elements of the German fleet.
It's certainly no exception for me to have a victory without more than 2-3 US troops crossing the ocean.

The 40 UK troops are another matter: the UK fleet & fighters protects them very, very well.

But the US is no problem.



ORIGINAL: oxford_guy

What about Hungary? Did they join the axis?

Yes, sorry, I forgot that country in the list. They joined too.
And Finland too, after I declared war in the USSR & got close to Leningrad.
Yogol
Posts: 219
Joined: Wed Nov 30, 2016 9:28 am

RE: Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by Yogol »

ORIGINAL: johnvmcnichols

Even with normal settings I had a hard time with the normal version of events, i.e Poland, then attack france, then turn against Soviets while holding UK in check and overrunning Africa.
Problem was always Soviet tech upgrades. I could never get deep enough into Russia before the odds turned against me. I could usually overrun Africa, but in the end it was too lengthy and the US would start invading in west africa or hit me as early as 43 in France. I tried a different approach:

What I do to deal with Africa is this...

a/ Even before Italy joins the war, I send several Italian troops to
The army in Tiranna, the army & corpse & HQ in northern Italy, they all go to Tobruk (having 2 HQs make a huge difference) before Italy even joins the war.

The main goal of that Italian force is to kill the pesky UK engineer and to hold it's ground in Mersa against the UK.


b/ I typically send a second German tank, a second German corps and two German armies to Africa too.
Once they arrive, the Italians retreat to Tiranna and go for Yugoslavia & Greece.

This is a heavy commitment. But once you have Cairo and later Gibraltar, you have pretty much secured all of north Africa for the rest of the war, which removes a major problem from your game.


c/ Once you have Cairo, you can move some German units back to Europe.
But keep at least the two tanks, one corps and the HQ in Africa and go to the Middle East: there are A LOT of MPPs to be won: Israel, Jordan, Syria, Iraq, Quawait, Persia... it all adds up.
(I never got Turkey to join, so I do not know if all those cities go to 8/10 when you conquer all of Africa and the entire Middle East, but that would give you even more reason to go after the Middle East).

Plus, those few troops will keep a whole lot of Russian troops busy once they reach southern Russia.


This

User avatar
Bylandt11
Posts: 85
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 5:01 pm

RE: Attack USSR ASAP? Or as late as possible?

Post by Bylandt11 »

ORIGINAL: Yogol

Because if you wait so long, Russia has so many troops (all with +2 experience) that you can not get to Moscow AND Leningrad AND Stalingrad: he has simply too many troops by then that are too strong. That +2 experience really, really hurts.

I did the same on normal difficulty level and that went very well, because without the +2 experience, you can kill up to 10 Russian troops per turn.
But with the +2 experience, every army in a city takes forever to kill :( [/i]

Thanks. Good advice.
Post Reply

Return to “Strategic Command WWII War in Europe”