RE: Advice please

[bigred]

Hi All. I produced an allied turn about 11pm. I then fell asleep. I woke up at 1130pm, then ended and locked the unprocessed pure allied turn then emailed it to FatR.

So next morning I get an email from FatR and he asked my why I did not send surface units after his KB. I thought I had.

So I looked at the file. I sent FatR the pure allied unprocessed turn in locked format. I immediately sent him the processed turn within 15 minutes of receipt of his replay and email comment.

If we play the unprocessed turn I loose two CVs. If we play my processed turn FatR looses 700 planes.

What should I do.

1. Play on with the unprocessed turn.

2. Ask FatR to except my processed turn.

3. Ask fatR to redo his turn.

[Jorge_Stanbury]

I would request option 3. But be ready / willing to do 1.

[crsutton]

ORIGINAL: Jorge_Stanbury

I would request option 3. But be ready / willing to do 1.

+1 It's his call not yours, sorry..

[bigred]

ORIGINAL: crsutton

ORIGINAL: Jorge_Stanbury

I would request option 3. But be ready / willing to do 1.

+1 It's his call not yours, sorry..

yes, I agree. Dont finish a turn if u are sleepy.

[witpqs]

Agree with the advice already posted.

[Rio Bravo]

ORIGINAL: witpqs

Agree with the advice already posted.

Seems the right thing to do, but damn, bummer.

[Itdepends]

What would FatR want if the tables were turned?
In my game with him we've both sent the turn a second time with additional orders, although only once each and before knowing the results of the replay.

Option 3 would be fair on both sides, option 2 would not assuming you saw the replay before sending the processed file. Option 1 would suck but the error was yours so sometimes you just have to "it up"

[leehunt27@bloomberg.net]

i think you have to play the turn you first sent. it was your error unfortunately. gotta own it, which sucks i know. but once a combat replay is engaged its no going back unless he's ok with it. then you have to be willing to do the same if it happens for him etc.

[rustysi]

Dont finish a turn if u are sleepy.

Just became one of my golden rules for PBEM. Don't really know what to say, other than ouch!!![:(]