CAUCASUS OIL
Moderators: Joel Billings, elmo3, Sabre21
CAUCASUS OIL
I have captured Baku and the entire north cost of the Caspian (late 43) and therefore have sealed off all Soviet oil from this source.
In game terms have I achieved anything tangible that will impact the Soviets over time or have I just been enjoying myself finding something for my paratroops to do?
I daresay if I could search the forum effectively I might have found this answer, sorry if I am duplicating earlier queries.
Thanks
In game terms have I achieved anything tangible that will impact the Soviets over time or have I just been enjoying myself finding something for my paratroops to do?
I daresay if I could search the forum effectively I might have found this answer, sorry if I am duplicating earlier queries.
Thanks
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
I believe Baku is the single largest source of oil production for the Soviets. Sections 21.1.5 and 21.2 in the manual discuss oil production and damage/repair.
We don't stop playing because we grow old, we grow old because we stop playing. - George Bernard Shaw
WitE alpha/beta tester
Sanctus Reach beta tester
Desert War 1940-42 beta tester
WitE alpha/beta tester
Sanctus Reach beta tester
Desert War 1940-42 beta tester
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
Baku is the largest (but by no means only) source of oil.
I don't know what the "real" effect will be on the game for you as far as how much it can and should cripple the Russian war economy. A lot will depend on how much of a stockpile there is. I suspect it will be less than you may think in terms of immediate results. The German war machine didn't cease when Rumania fell, which was the Germans largest oil source.
I don't know what the "real" effect will be on the game for you as far as how much it can and should cripple the Russian war economy. A lot will depend on how much of a stockpile there is. I suspect it will be less than you may think in terms of immediate results. The German war machine didn't cease when Rumania fell, which was the Germans largest oil source.
-
- Posts: 16
- Joined: Tue May 15, 2012 2:07 pm
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
Germany was creating an enormous amount of synthetic fuel at that point however. It wasn't enough, even in combination with the Romanian oil fields, to fuel the entire Wehrmacht, but it certainly helped. I'm fairly certain the USSR did not have the capability to do so.ORIGINAL: Klydon
Baku is the largest (but by no means only) source of oil.
I don't know what the "real" effect will be on the game for you as far as how much it can and should cripple the Russian war economy. A lot will depend on how much of a stockpile there is. I suspect it will be less than you may think in terms of immediate results. The German war machine didn't cease when Rumania fell, which was the Germans largest oil source.
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
ORIGINAL: Panzer Meyer
Germany was creating an enormous amount of synthetic fuel at that point however. It wasn't enough, even in combination with the Romanian oil fields, to fuel the entire Wehrmacht, but it certainly helped. I'm fairly certain the USSR did not have the capability to do so.
But the Sovs developed other sources of oil in the Volga region, Ural Mountains, Kazakhstan and Central Asia.
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
ORIGINAL: Panzer Meyer
Germany was creating an enormous amount of synthetic fuel at that point however. It wasn't enough, even in combination with the Romanian oil fields, to fuel the entire Wehrmacht, but it certainly helped. I'm fairly certain the USSR did not have the capability to do so.ORIGINAL: Klydon
Baku is the largest (but by no means only) source of oil.
I don't know what the "real" effect will be on the game for you as far as how much it can and should cripple the Russian war economy. A lot will depend on how much of a stockpile there is. I suspect it will be less than you may think in terms of immediate results. The German war machine didn't cease when Rumania fell, which was the Germans largest oil source.
The Russians did not, but they had other sources not in the Caucasus.
By the time Rumania fell, the synth industry was pretty much rubble as it was very easy to spot and very vulnerable to strategic air power. It was also pretty much top priority on the bombing list of "things to bomb" as far as the Western Allies were concerned in the rightful notion that the entire Wehrmacht would be affected, including the Luftwaffe.
Make no mistake, it would have hurt the Russians greviously to lose the oil resources there, but it would have taken awhile for it to take effect and it wasn't like the Germans were going to do anything with it either since the rail lines were a mess and the Germans didn't even have close to enough rolling stock to move it even if the rail lines were not a mess.
-
- Posts: 16
- Joined: Tue May 15, 2012 2:07 pm
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
Quite right Klydon. A quick check of some sources reveals that by 1944 Germany was producing almost 60% of its oil and 100% of its aviation fuel synthetically. The allied bombing campaign almost completely wiped out synthetic production capacity by the fall of that same year. Coupled with the successful bombing of Ploesti and eventually the loss of Romania, Germany was literally paralyzed.
However I think a similar fate would have befallen the Soviet Union if they were to lose the Caucasus. I'll have to double check when I get home, but I am fairly certain that 80% or more of all Soviet oil production came from that region.
However I think a similar fate would have befallen the Soviet Union if they were to lose the Caucasus. I'll have to double check when I get home, but I am fairly certain that 80% or more of all Soviet oil production came from that region.
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
ORIGINAL: Panzer Meyer
However I think a similar fate would have befallen the Soviet Union if they were to lose the Caucasus. I'll have to double check when I get home, but I am fairly certain that 80% or more of all Soviet oil production came from that region.
Not unless Germany can park a panzer army in Texas.
Lend Lease would've made up any shortfall in oil. Although this would have come at the expense of other shipments, presumably.
WitE Alpha Tester
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
http://www.azer.com/aiweb/categories/ma ... _ww22.html
Because of the crisis, the State Defense Committee decided to transfer the main forces of oil-workers and oil enterprises of Baku to the regions of Volga, Ural Mountains, Kazakhstan and Central Asia for the enforcement of the oil extraction there. In October, 1942, more than ten thousand oil workers left for these eastern parts.
All the nine drilling offices, oil-expedition and oil-construction trusts as well as various other enterprises with their staffs were transferred to an area near Kuybishev, (Russia Federation in Tartarstan near the Ural Mountains north of Kazakhstan). This city soon came to be known as "the Second Baku" as highly qualified specialists and masters in oil industry were sent there along with more than 5,000 workers as well as half of the equipment.
Despite the severe frost the drillers started searching for oil. Winter was over but spring brought torrential rains and flooding. The small river, Kinel, overflowed its banks and the water rose 3-4 meters, flooding the mouths of wells, causing considerable loss of oil. The Bakuis, who were up to their waists in the icy water, defended the wells. All in all, with such determined efforts, the new Bakuis in the region of Povolzhye, increased the fuel extraction in "Kinelneft" trust that first year by 66% and by 42% in entire region of Kuybishev.
They did it the "Bakui way" which meant not allowing the decrease of oil extraction or cessation of drilling in winter; working in winter as hard as in summer, working at night as much as in daytime; and generally increasing the oil extraction by any means possible. As a result, five new oil and gas fields were discovered and huge oil refinery construction projects were undertaken, including the first pipe line between Kuybishev and Buturslan was built that same year. The pipeline rendered a tremendous service to defense factories saving them the trouble of importing coal and mazut (black oil) from remote places.
A number of large modern oil refineries were also built in Kuybishev. But the most significant assistance that Bakuis gave was in extracting oil from the Devonian Strata in Kuybishev for the first time (June 9, 1944). This historical event marked the beginning of industrial development unprecedented in its volume. It made it possible to restore oil extraction to pre-war levels and Russia became the largest oil industry power in the entire world.
Because of the crisis, the State Defense Committee decided to transfer the main forces of oil-workers and oil enterprises of Baku to the regions of Volga, Ural Mountains, Kazakhstan and Central Asia for the enforcement of the oil extraction there. In October, 1942, more than ten thousand oil workers left for these eastern parts.
All the nine drilling offices, oil-expedition and oil-construction trusts as well as various other enterprises with their staffs were transferred to an area near Kuybishev, (Russia Federation in Tartarstan near the Ural Mountains north of Kazakhstan). This city soon came to be known as "the Second Baku" as highly qualified specialists and masters in oil industry were sent there along with more than 5,000 workers as well as half of the equipment.
Despite the severe frost the drillers started searching for oil. Winter was over but spring brought torrential rains and flooding. The small river, Kinel, overflowed its banks and the water rose 3-4 meters, flooding the mouths of wells, causing considerable loss of oil. The Bakuis, who were up to their waists in the icy water, defended the wells. All in all, with such determined efforts, the new Bakuis in the region of Povolzhye, increased the fuel extraction in "Kinelneft" trust that first year by 66% and by 42% in entire region of Kuybishev.
They did it the "Bakui way" which meant not allowing the decrease of oil extraction or cessation of drilling in winter; working in winter as hard as in summer, working at night as much as in daytime; and generally increasing the oil extraction by any means possible. As a result, five new oil and gas fields were discovered and huge oil refinery construction projects were undertaken, including the first pipe line between Kuybishev and Buturslan was built that same year. The pipeline rendered a tremendous service to defense factories saving them the trouble of importing coal and mazut (black oil) from remote places.
A number of large modern oil refineries were also built in Kuybishev. But the most significant assistance that Bakuis gave was in extracting oil from the Devonian Strata in Kuybishev for the first time (June 9, 1944). This historical event marked the beginning of industrial development unprecedented in its volume. It made it possible to restore oil extraction to pre-war levels and Russia became the largest oil industry power in the entire world.
Watched a documentary on beavers. Best dam documentary I've ever seen.
-
- Posts: 713
- Joined: Wed Jul 21, 2004 1:29 pm
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
So, no, Baku and Ploesti have no effect on the game that I have found. Against the Soviet AI, I even laid track and rebuilt all of Baku's facilities, but it made little difference, save perhaps to the umodelled Naval Forces.
-
- Posts: 50
- Joined: Sun Mar 27, 2011 11:29 pm
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
ORIGINAL: Flaviusx
ORIGINAL: Panzer Meyer
However I think a similar fate would have befallen the Soviet Union if they were to lose the Caucasus. I'll have to double check when I get home, but I am fairly certain that 80% or more of all Soviet oil production came from that region.
Not unless Germany can park a panzer army in Texas.
Lend Lease would've made up any shortfall in oil. Although this would have come at the expense of other shipments, presumably.
And the United States would presumably produce a fleet of oil tankers out of thin air to bring this oil to the USSR. The United States had issues in 1942 thru early 1943 keeping its Pacific Fleet supplied with bunker fuel because of an extreme shortage of tankers. Yet the USA would apparently – under your nonsensical blathering’s about fuel and fuel supplies – have the magical capability to instantly keep the Red Army, Red Air Force and Red Industry topped off with fuel, oil, lubricants and etc. after Baku is lost? Please. You really haven't the foggiest idea as to the magitude involved with such an undertaking.
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
ORIGINAL: johnnyvagas
ORIGINAL: Flaviusx
ORIGINAL: Panzer Meyer
However I think a similar fate would have befallen the Soviet Union if they were to lose the Caucasus. I'll have to double check when I get home, but I am fairly certain that 80% or more of all Soviet oil production came from that region.
Not unless Germany can park a panzer army in Texas.
Lend Lease would've made up any shortfall in oil. Although this would have come at the expense of other shipments, presumably.
And the United States would presumably produce a fleet of oil tankers out of thin air to bring this oil to the USSR. The United States had issues in 1942 thru early 1943 keeping its Pacific Fleet supplied with bunker fuel because of an extreme shortage of tankers. Yet the USA would apparently – under your nonsensical blathering’s about fuel and fuel supplies – have the magical capability to instantly keep the Red Army, Red Air Force and Red Industry topped off with fuel, oil, lubricants and etc. after Baku is lost? Please. You really haven't the foggiest idea as to the magitude involved with such an undertaking.
You do know that the war in Europe was priotity #1? Doubtfull.
I don't have the exact number handy, (the book is in the car and I'm not), but between 2-3 million tons of oil was sent by lend lease.
Watched a documentary on beavers. Best dam documentary I've ever seen.
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
Adjustments would have to be made, no doubt. But it would have happened.
WitE Alpha Tester
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
I'm with the camp that capturing baku would have serious consequences for the Soviet war machine. It would certainly have put them back by years.
As others have remarked, having the crude is one thing, refining it is something else, getting it to were it can be used is again something else entirely. The logistics involved in moving huge amount of refined oil products to the Soviets are breathtaking!
It would have had serious effects, period.
As others have remarked, having the crude is one thing, refining it is something else, getting it to were it can be used is again something else entirely. The logistics involved in moving huge amount of refined oil products to the Soviets are breathtaking!
It would have had serious effects, period.
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
Can we use the editor to adjust and limit the other sources of oil on the map to make Baku and/or Ploesti more important?
Although I have not playted German yet, it seems like we dont need any more modifications to make their life harder.
Although I have not playted German yet, it seems like we dont need any more modifications to make their life harder.
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
ORIGINAL: glvaca
I'm with the camp that capturing baku would have serious consequences for the Soviet war machine. It would certainly have put them back by years.
As others have remarked, having the crude is one thing, refining it is something else, getting it to were it can be used is again something else entirely. The logistics involved in moving huge amount of refined oil products to the Soviets are breathtaking!
It would have had serious effects, period.
Maybe. But Kuybuyshev made up for it.
Watched a documentary on beavers. Best dam documentary I've ever seen.
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
ORIGINAL: Brandle
Can we use the editor to adjust and limit the other sources of oil on the map to make Baku and/or Ploesti more important?
Although I have not playted German yet, it seems like we dont need any more modifications to make their life harder.
Not sure about the editor but I have my doubts. Others will be better placed to answer that.
Play the Germans first before coming to conclusions. Read the AAR's too. The Sovs don't exactly have a pick-nick in 1941! But this isn't about balance for me. More about the correct effects of a successful strategy by the Germans which deserves to be rewarded.
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
ORIGINAL: Aurelian
ORIGINAL: glvaca
I'm with the camp that capturing baku would have serious consequences for the Soviet war machine. It would certainly have put them back by years.
As others have remarked, having the crude is one thing, refining it is something else, getting it to were it can be used is again something else entirely. The logistics involved in moving huge amount of refined oil products to the Soviets are breathtaking!
It would have had serious effects, period.
Maybe. But Kuybuyshev made up for it.
".....As a result, five new oil and gas fields were discovered and huge oil refinery construction projects were undertaken, including the first pipe line between Kuybishev and Buturslan was built that same year. The pipeline rendered a tremendous service to defense factories saving them the trouble of importing coal and mazut (black oil) from remote places.
A number of large modern oil refineries were also built in Kuybishev. But the most significant assistance that Bakuis gave was in extracting oil from the Devonian Strata in Kuybishev for the first time (June 9, 1944). This historical event marked the beginning of industrial development unprecedented in its volume. It made it possible to restore oil extraction to pre-war levels and Russia became the largest oil industry power in the entire world."
There is quite a difference between discovering oil, and actually producing enough to replace the lost production which takes years of devellopment.
I'm not arguing the Sovs would have lost the war without Baku oil, I am saying it would have put them back for years.
RE: CAUCASUS OIL
Men, do a search (if it works ^^), the topic was discussed a couple times with (in my opinion) sound arguments and numbers. The fall of Baku wouldn't have impacted Russian's fighting ability as early as you may expect (they had stockpiled a little bit...) and wouldn't have benefited Nazi Germany before quite a long, long time. In a way or another, it is not something that important from a gaming point of view considering the scale of WitE.