Tech trading needs some love

Distant Worlds is a vast, pausable real-time, 4X space strategy game which models a "living galaxy" with incredible options for replayability and customizability. Experience the full depth and detail of large turn-based strategy games, but with the simplicity and ease of real-time, and on the scale of a massively-multiplayer online game. Now greatly enhanced with the new Universe release, which includes all four previous releases as well as the new Universe expansion!

Moderators: elliotg, Icemania

DasTactic
Posts: 1339
Joined: Mon Oct 10, 2005 7:16 am

Tech trading needs some love

Post by DasTactic »

The tech trading mechanic (as well as the scrap ship and steal research mechanics) in the game feels a little like an exploit.

I think it would be great if instead of immediately acquiring the tech you trade - it gives you a 50% credit in remaining research and gives you the 3-times speed boost (can't recall the name of this function in the game).

That way you still need to put in some research time to get the tech. This would still force specialisation and help with the strategic choices.

Race-specific tech would need to be a special case where if you gain 50% of the research it then becomes available for your race to finish the research.

Anyone else got any thoughts about this?
User avatar
Gelatinous Cube
Posts: 696
Joined: Wed Oct 26, 2011 2:34 am

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by Gelatinous Cube »

I really do think no tech trading at all is the way to go, but instead maybe let good allies work on joint projects to improve eachother's understanding of eachother's different techs, slowly and incrementally?

Consider Babylon 5, where it was only at the VERY END of the five year story-arc that that one race of pretty girls decided that they *might* give the humans some Anti-grav tech.

I know people will say "But just don't use it!" Okay. Got it. Don't have to use it. Sometimes I do, sometimes I don't. All I'm saying is there's room for a better system.
User avatar
feelotraveller
Posts: 1040
Joined: Mon Sep 12, 2011 10:08 am

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by feelotraveller »

I think that this area could certainly do with some love.

Joint research projects* sounds like a good idea, but maybe limit them to one in each field (Energy, Weapons, Hi Tech - allowing for balancing research costs) per empire and require some investment of cash but working out cheaper than crashing research. Negotiation for the actual techs in the joint research project could be quite involved. Could also lose all accumulated research if the relationship with your partner sours before the end. The benefits would be mutual but the speed based on combined research caps. If it was one of each field for each empire you had a joint research project with it would keep the diplomatic advantages/disadvantages of races in play.

In this case 'just don't do it' does not really apply as the computer will do it, and prolifically. (Sometimes I like to hamstring myself by house rule of no tech trading but it limits you quite a lot diplomatically.)

* I remember the tech treaties from MOO2 where you would pay and after a while the tech boost would kick in. That was good until you played harder levels where it was repulsive for the win.
User avatar
AminMaalouf
Posts: 176
Joined: Sat Jan 06, 2007 1:45 pm

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by AminMaalouf »

Tech trading, stealing tech has been harder since Legends. I simply do not make a lot of use of these features most of the time, although these are a features I would not want to miss in the game.
User avatar
Gelatinous Cube
Posts: 696
Joined: Wed Oct 26, 2011 2:34 am

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by Gelatinous Cube »

I'm not too picky about how much it costs.. the idea is that getting tech from other races should be a more meaningful experience. Something you do *in addition* to your own research. All the money in the universe shouldn't be able to buy you all the tech. I think tech trading should be the result of long and good relations with another race, and then some money for a cherry on top.

Just my two cents though.
User avatar
Gray Death
Posts: 63
Joined: Fri May 04, 2007 4:34 am
Location: Germany

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by Gray Death »

The racial techs are, where I am after. What I cant get trough spying, I will get trough trading. ;)

The Dhayyut Velocity drive is always top of my prority list.
User avatar
AminMaalouf
Posts: 176
Joined: Sat Jan 06, 2007 1:45 pm

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by AminMaalouf »

I hope one day we get species specific tech trees with lots of unique toys.
User avatar
Gray Death
Posts: 63
Joined: Fri May 04, 2007 4:34 am
Location: Germany

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by Gray Death »

That would be very nice, or how it is in Sword of the Stars. I mean randomized tech tree with some core techs everyone becomes.
User avatar
Xerberus86
Posts: 2
Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2011 6:58 pm

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by Xerberus86 »

why make it so complicated, i would made it like in galciv2 (i think). there you would ge bonus points in research, if you would have an research pact. something like this should be easy to come by in dw too. if you make an research pact / contract, you would get some research points for the selected research category, like an additional lab. let's say it would be a percentage of the research capacity of the other empire. in this case i would also limit the amount of research contracts an empire would sign, maybe to two or three.

greetz
User avatar
Gelatinous Cube
Posts: 696
Joined: Wed Oct 26, 2011 2:34 am

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by Gelatinous Cube »

ORIGINAL: Xerberus86

why make it so complicated, i would made it like in galciv2 (i think). there you would ge bonus points in research, if you would have an research pact. something like this should be easy to come by in dw too. if you make an research pact / contract, you would get some research points for the selected research category, like an additional lab. let's say it would be a percentage of the research capacity of the other empire. in this case i would also limit the amount of research contracts an empire would sign, maybe to two or three.

greetz

With all due respect, they eventually added a "No Tech Trading" option in GalCiv2 for the exact same reasons that many people don't like tech trading here.
User avatar
feelotraveller
Posts: 1040
Joined: Mon Sep 12, 2011 10:08 am

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by feelotraveller »

ORIGINAL: Xerberus86

why make it so complicated, i would made it like in galciv2 (i think). there you would ge bonus points in research, if you would have an research pact. something like this should be easy to come by in dw too. if you make an research pact / contract, you would get some research points for the selected research category, like an additional lab. let's say it would be a percentage of the research capacity of the other empire. in this case i would also limit the amount of research contracts an empire would sign, maybe to two or three.

greetz

One good reason is that the tech leader, if sufficiently advanced, will not gain anything from research treaties. You will need to find an empire with tech you want but don't know and who wants some of your tech which they don't know. Of course the computer would be set up (generally) to not want to get the raw end of any research deal... It is not just a general 'more research' mechanism but one of diplomatic bargaining, and possibly, counter-offer. These techs for those techs? No, no, we want that one. Well, how about...?

Secondly it is good to have some cases where you will lose out from making a research pact and to require you to maintain decent relations with your research partners (and not just to attain decent relations momentarily to make the treaty). The money requirement is to make sure that these cannot just be spammed with everyone right from the beginning of the game. Putting a hard cap on the number of research treaties will work against the diplomatic powerhouses who you would expect to be able to make more treaties than xenophobic isolationist races.
Evil Steve
Posts: 47
Joined: Wed Jul 21, 2010 8:36 pm

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by Evil Steve »

personally, I feel that techs specific to available resources as specified by planet type (ie racial) would be great. if you trade for tech, you have to have the "exotic" resources to manufacture it, which implies trading ties with the source of the exotic tach, and adds to the strategic game in terms of sourcing resources for the tech.

Steve
Cauldyth
Posts: 932
Joined: Sun Jun 27, 2010 1:24 am

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by Cauldyth »

Add me to the list of people in favour of a No Tech Trading toggle in game setup, at the very least.

At a more sophisticated level, the other ideas mentioned here sound good too. Trading only getting you to maximum X% of completion on a project, tech trading just giving a boost to research, etc. I would really love a Diplomacy-focused third expansion to Distant Worlds that fleshes things like this out. [;)]
User avatar
Evrett
Posts: 142
Joined: Tue Nov 29, 2011 6:22 pm

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by Evrett »

I play on "expensive" research settings and I'm ok with the overall costs and functions of tech trading. That said I feel "buying" a new tech should feel like HUGE burden on your economy and a choice you make only is specific situations. Currently, while expensive, I still have a "oh need to check the races for new techs to buy" feeling. I still cant afford most tech but the feeling could be helped to be less casual.

A tech trading off option or no brokering where you cant sell stuff you didnt invent yourself seems reasonable and I'd be in favor of that. Or perhaps an "x credits per month for x months" as sort of a tech "rental" contract.

I've seen races get really advanced single tech and I'm wondering if this is from the scraping option. If never used this since having cap ships early is such a benefit..how does it work?

"The nine most terrifying words in the English language are: 'I'm from the government and I'm here to help.'" - Ronald Reagan
Jerkface
Posts: 28
Joined: Tue Dec 06, 2011 12:46 pm

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by Jerkface »

Just starting playing with legends.  Tech trading is still way too powerful. Short term, a no-tech trade game option would be nice.  Long term, the idea of two parties working together on the same project? Very cool.  Not sure about retiring and exploiting tech...perhaps an option to turn that off as well.  Right now it seems keeping recovered ancient ships seems much more useful than retiring them, so maybe working as designed.
User avatar
Grotius
Posts: 5842
Joined: Fri Oct 18, 2002 5:34 pm
Location: The Imperial Palace.

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by Grotius »

I also agree, at a minimum I'd like a no-tech-trading toggle. There's no way to do that now?

I wouldn't even mind an option that allowed the AIs to trade tech among themselves but denied me the same privilege -- a cheat that might help the AI and make the game more challenging. But that too would have to be an option that could be toggled off, because I imagine most people wouldn't want to use it. Me, I don't mind a cheating AI. :)

Longer-term, I'd love tech trees that change from game to game, or race-specific tech trees, or (ideally) both.
Image
User avatar
Shark7
Posts: 7936
Joined: Tue Jul 24, 2007 4:11 pm
Location: The Big Nowhere

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by Shark7 »

ORIGINAL: Grotius

I also agree, at a minimum I'd like a no-tech-trading toggle. There's no way to do that now?

I wouldn't even mind an option that allowed the AIs to trade tech among themselves but denied me the same privilege -- a cheat that might help the AI and make the game more challenging. But that too would have to be an option that could be toggled off, because I imagine most people wouldn't want to use it. Me, I don't mind a cheating AI. :)

Longer-term, I'd love tech trees that change from game to game, or race-specific tech trees, or (ideally) both.

On the other hand, I've been known to trade techs to keep empires alive that I want to keep. I also do it to make the game harder on myself. I just wish the reputation bonus for a tech trade was nixed.
Distant Worlds Fan

'When in doubt...attack!'
Spacecadet
Posts: 1784
Joined: Sun Apr 18, 2010 5:52 pm

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by Spacecadet »

Compared to other versions of DW, Tech Trading now is far more difficult than it has ever been.

Playing with Extreme Slow Tech Research speed, you'll see that it is really much more difficult.
CPU: Intel 2700K
RAM: 16 GB
GPU: GTX 970
OS: Windows 7 (64 bit)
Res: 1920 x 1200


User avatar
Grisha
Posts: 273
Joined: Thu May 11, 2000 4:00 pm
Location: Seattle

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by Grisha »

I agree that it might be ideal to make traded techs have a delayed component to them as you suggest, Das. I don't think it's a good idea to do away with tech trading though. It would destroy the uniqueness of the Zenox and Quameno races who live off tech trading, rather than commerce.

ORIGINAL: Das123

The tech trading mechanic (as well as the scrap ship and steal research mechanics) in the game feels a little like an exploit.

I think it would be great if instead of immediately acquiring the tech you trade - it gives you a 50% credit in remaining research and gives you the 3-times speed boost (can't recall the name of this function in the game).

That way you still need to put in some research time to get the tech. This would still force specialisation and help with the strategic choices.

Race-specific tech would need to be a special case where if you gain 50% of the research it then becomes available for your race to finish the research.

Anyone else got any thoughts about this?
Best regards,
Greg Guerrero
DasTactic
Posts: 1339
Joined: Mon Oct 10, 2005 7:16 am

RE: Tech trading needs some love

Post by DasTactic »

If there was a toggle switch to turn tech trading off I would have it turned off for now.

Raising the price is not really a good option because all you would need to do is research a high level tech and the price difference would be negated.

I like the idea of a diplomatic tech treaty where a percentage of each empire's tech ability is added to the other empire - say 10% or 20%. That would be a good addition even if the actual tech trading itself was tweaked.

Maybe its as simple as not allowing tech trading for techs worth more that $X where $X is around $200k to $500k. That way the low level techs can be traded easily but you can only access the higher level techs by completing  a proportion of the research yourself. Of course - this would stop the trade of race-specific techs which I wouldn't really mind much.
Post Reply

Return to “Distant Worlds 1 Series”