The Greatest Tank Ever
Moderator: MOD_SPWaW
- V22 Osprey
- Posts: 1593
- Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 2:07 pm
- Location: Corona, CA
The Greatest Tank Ever
Here's the Hall of Fame of Tanks.
Post Your vote in this thread.
My vote:M1A1 abrams
[:D]
Post Your vote in this thread.
My vote:M1A1 abrams
[:D]
Art by rogueusmc.
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
In comparison to other tanks of the same time period? WW2...I would have to go with the T34. Pretty revolutionary design, easy to maintain and produce, excellent reliability, great armor, and easy to operate.
Contemporary... Probably the M1A1, though the Challenger is a very close second.
Pure badass on the battlefield, ignoring production, reliability, etc - the Tiger.
For the Hall of Fame thing - that has to be earned - we'll see... [;)]
Goblin
Contemporary... Probably the M1A1, though the Challenger is a very close second.
Pure badass on the battlefield, ignoring production, reliability, etc - the Tiger.
For the Hall of Fame thing - that has to be earned - we'll see... [;)]
Goblin
-
- Posts: 581
- Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2005 11:49 pm
- Location: Japan
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
I like the upgraded Sherman. Shermans were easy to make (highest number of any tank ever built), look nice and are good all-round tanks. The panzer III fully upgraded was a very nice tank too and did good work in all theatres.
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
According to Wiki, and other sites, the M4 and its variants were produced to just above 50,000 units total (all time). The T-34 had over 57,000 units produced before 1945, and over 84,000 built total (all time).
Goblin
Goblin
- Arctic Blast
- Posts: 1157
- Joined: Wed Apr 04, 2007 5:58 am
- Contact:
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
I would have to concur with the T34 for WW2 era. For the modern tank, the newest Leopard 2A6. the Abrams is a little too vulnerable to heatseeking AT weapons with that blowtorch of an exhaust shooting out the back end of it.
Meditation on inevitable death should be performed daily.
-
- Posts: 532
- Joined: Thu Aug 02, 2001 8:00 am
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
no "alltime"-besttankever exist.
Why? Cause a T34 from 1940 was superior to any other 1940-tank, but compared to a hummer with tow it is toast.
Every tank can only rated in its time.
So: in ww2 its for me
1.) Tiger I
2.) Panther
3.) T34-85
Modern Times:
1.) Leclerc
2.) Leopard2M6/ChallengerII
3.) M1Abrahams
But the problem with the modern tanks is, they never fought in a real war under combat-tank-circumstances.
The slaughter of iraqi T72 with full air support could be done with M48... so no real test.
WW2 was the last real contest for tanks. Result: Like everything, mass beats quality. Esp. if the mass has air/art-support.
Why? Cause a T34 from 1940 was superior to any other 1940-tank, but compared to a hummer with tow it is toast.
Every tank can only rated in its time.
So: in ww2 its for me
1.) Tiger I
2.) Panther
3.) T34-85
Modern Times:
1.) Leclerc
2.) Leopard2M6/ChallengerII
3.) M1Abrahams
But the problem with the modern tanks is, they never fought in a real war under combat-tank-circumstances.
The slaughter of iraqi T72 with full air support could be done with M48... so no real test.
WW2 was the last real contest for tanks. Result: Like everything, mass beats quality. Esp. if the mass has air/art-support.
Don't tickle yourself with some moralist crap thinking we have some sort of obligation to help these people. We're there for our self-interest, and anything we do to be 'nice' should be considered a courtesy dweebespit
-
- Posts: 581
- Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2005 11:49 pm
- Location: Japan
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
As for WW2, the sherman is the hands-down winner for best overall tank. As for today, the Lamborghini of tanks is the Merkava Mk.4. If you don't agree then talk to the barrel...
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
I recall reading something about two Tigers on patrol destroying dozen T-34... And anyone, who has played Gulf War scenarios of WinSPMBT, should know what couple Abrams and Chargers will do to dozen T-50. So much about numerical superiority [:'(]WW2 was the last real contest for tanks. Result: Like everything, mass beats quality. Esp. if the mass has air/art-support.
[edit]
IMO best tank in SPWAW is Panther: well protected but fast, and penetration value exceeds Tiger's 88 [;)]
You know what they say, don't you? About how us MechWarriors are the modern knights, how warfare has become civilized now that we have to abide by conventions and rules of war. Don't believe it.
MekWars
MekWars
- FlashfyreSP
- Posts: 1192
- Joined: Sat Jul 06, 2002 9:39 am
- Location: Combat Information Center
- Contact:
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
ORIGINAL: Matti Kuokkanen
I recall reading something about two Tigers on patrol destroying dozen T-34... And anyone, who has played Gulf War scenarios of WinSPMBT, should know what couple Abrams and Chargers will do to dozen T-50. So much about numerical superiority [:'(]WW2 was the last real contest for tanks. Result: Like everything, mass beats quality. Esp. if the mass has air/art-support.
[edit]
IMO best tank in SPWAW is Panther: well protected but fast, and penetration value exceeds Tiger's 88 [;)]
Shouldn't base your choice on what a game depicts...computer games are by no means accurate as to the realities of combat. Many aspects of the battlefield are not able to be computer modelled, making them poor substitutes for scientific research.
- V22 Osprey
- Posts: 1593
- Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 2:07 pm
- Location: Corona, CA
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
Ok,post like this:
Best Tank of WW2:
(Your list here)
Best Tank of Modern:
(Your List here)
Best Tank of WW2:
(Your list here)
Best Tank of Modern:
(Your List here)
Art by rogueusmc.
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
Uh... what's this forum again?ORIGINAL: FlashfyreSP
ORIGINAL: Matti Kuokkanen
I recall reading something about two Tigers on patrol destroying dozen T-34... And anyone, who has played Gulf War scenarios of WinSPMBT, should know what couple Abrams and Chargers will do to dozen T-50. So much about numerical superiority [:'(]WW2 was the last real contest for tanks. Result: Like everything, mass beats quality. Esp. if the mass has air/art-support.
[edit]
IMO best tank in SPWAW is Panther: well protected but fast, and penetration value exceeds Tiger's 88 [;)]
Shouldn't base your choice on what a game depicts...computer games are by no means accurate as to the realities of combat. Many aspects of the battlefield are not able to be computer modelled, making them poor substitutes for scientific research.
You know what they say, don't you? About how us MechWarriors are the modern knights, how warfare has become civilized now that we have to abide by conventions and rules of war. Don't believe it.
MekWars
MekWars
- FlashfyreSP
- Posts: 1192
- Joined: Sat Jul 06, 2002 9:39 am
- Location: Combat Information Center
- Contact:
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
ORIGINAL: Matti Kuokkanen
Uh... what's this forum again?ORIGINAL: FlashfyreSP
ORIGINAL: Matti Kuokkanen
I recall reading something about two Tigers on patrol destroying dozen T-34... And anyone, who has played Gulf War scenarios of WinSPMBT, should know what couple Abrams and Chargers will do to dozen T-50. So much about numerical superiority [:'(]
[edit]
IMO best tank in SPWAW is Panther: well protected but fast, and penetration value exceeds Tiger's 88 [;)]
Shouldn't base your choice on what a game depicts...computer games are by no means accurate as to the realities of combat. Many aspects of the battlefield are not able to be computer modelled, making them poor substitutes for scientific research.
You referred to how the WinSPMBT game depicts combat between modern tanks. I simply pointed out that you probably shouldn't use a computer game as a source of relevant research. It is by no means indicative of how a given weapons system operates in the real world. Game designers do an awful lot of "fudging" and abstracting of data to make the game work; in most cases at the expense of real operational abilities.
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
Oh, righto... I thought you were referring to my comment about Panther's penetration value [8|]ORIGINAL: FlashfyreSP
You referred to how the WinSPMBT game depicts combat between modern tanks.
You know what they say, don't you? About how us MechWarriors are the modern knights, how warfare has become civilized now that we have to abide by conventions and rules of war. Don't believe it.
MekWars
MekWars
- FlashfyreSP
- Posts: 1192
- Joined: Sat Jul 06, 2002 9:39 am
- Location: Combat Information Center
- Contact:
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
ORIGINAL: Matti Kuokkanen
Oh, righto... I thought you were referring to my comment about Panther's penetration value [8|]ORIGINAL: FlashfyreSP
You referred to how the WinSPMBT game depicts combat between modern tanks.
Still, the topic is "best tank in the world", not "best tank in SPWAW".
- V22 Osprey
- Posts: 1593
- Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 2:07 pm
- Location: Corona, CA
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
For WW 2 it's a toss up between the T34 and the Sherman. I firmly believe the Abrams is the best of the modern era.
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
For me, it's the Matilda II.
Reduce SP:WaW slaughter, "Low Carnage":
Settings: 80Spot,80Hit,100R/R,XXXTQ,110TkT,150InfT,180AvSoft,130AvArm,150SOFire / Command & Ctrl ON / AutoRally OFF
Enhanced http://enhanced.freeforums.org
Depot https://www.tapatalk.com/groups/spwawdepot/
Settings: 80Spot,80Hit,100R/R,XXXTQ,110TkT,150InfT,180AvSoft,130AvArm,150SOFire / Command & Ctrl ON / AutoRally OFF
Enhanced http://enhanced.freeforums.org
Depot https://www.tapatalk.com/groups/spwawdepot/
-
- Posts: 581
- Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2005 11:49 pm
- Location: Japan
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
Modern tanks are hard to compare cause they tend to copy each other and have never fought. Most probably they will become obsolete and replaced without a war to prove which is the best. The only case was when the Abrams beat up the T-72s of Iraq so easily but the T-72s were a couple of decades behind in tech, and the Israelis tested-out various tanks in their wars.
Some tanks have a niche advantage like the Russian tanks have the best mobility and the Abrams has a good gun (but no missile). As mentioned, I like the Merkava Mk4 cause it has the best crew protection of any tank. The Abrams and Leopard 2 designs load the armor onto the front hull, while the Merkava, thanks to frequent tank fights with the arabs, know the best way to protect the whole tank. As for the crew, Israelis are the best trained with the highest morale and train with lazers shut off and hitting targets (leftover Syrian tank wrecks) on the first shot while on the move with iron sights. So with crews doubly effective compared to other nations and a well-protected hull, the Merkavas would perform the best in a tank battle.
Merkava also wins easily for style. The family drove their Merkava to the stadium for an event and it had no problem clearing out most of the bleachers for a good choice of seats.
Some tanks have a niche advantage like the Russian tanks have the best mobility and the Abrams has a good gun (but no missile). As mentioned, I like the Merkava Mk4 cause it has the best crew protection of any tank. The Abrams and Leopard 2 designs load the armor onto the front hull, while the Merkava, thanks to frequent tank fights with the arabs, know the best way to protect the whole tank. As for the crew, Israelis are the best trained with the highest morale and train with lazers shut off and hitting targets (leftover Syrian tank wrecks) on the first shot while on the move with iron sights. So with crews doubly effective compared to other nations and a well-protected hull, the Merkavas would perform the best in a tank battle.
Merkava also wins easily for style. The family drove their Merkava to the stadium for an event and it had no problem clearing out most of the bleachers for a good choice of seats.
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
WWII, I say probably the T34. While it wasn't perfect by any means, it was cheap to build, fairly effective with the larger gun, reliable, and had the best armor pretty much of any medium tank.
Modern, I'd go with the Israeli Merkava. There is no other tank I'd rather be in when the poopy hits the proverbial fan. But it's a lot closer now-a-days, since most everyone sells or trades the tech around; pretty much every modern MBT has some variation of the same Chobham (sp?) armor, and a big main gun using HEAT rounds.
I just like the Merkava because it was designed with crew survivability in mind as well as battle field effectiveness. Which makes more sense, since a tank is only as effective as it's crew.
Modern, I'd go with the Israeli Merkava. There is no other tank I'd rather be in when the poopy hits the proverbial fan. But it's a lot closer now-a-days, since most everyone sells or trades the tech around; pretty much every modern MBT has some variation of the same Chobham (sp?) armor, and a big main gun using HEAT rounds.
I just like the Merkava because it was designed with crew survivability in mind as well as battle field effectiveness. Which makes more sense, since a tank is only as effective as it's crew.
"Wait... Holden was a cat. Suddenly it makes sense."
RE: The Greatest Tank Ever
120 and 125 mm smoothbores seems to be very common MBT weapons.ORIGINAL: azraelck
since most everyone sells or trades the tech around; pretty much every modern MBT has some variation of the same Chobham (sp?) armor, and a big main gun using HEAT rounds.
You know what they say, don't you? About how us MechWarriors are the modern knights, how warfare has become civilized now that we have to abide by conventions and rules of war. Don't believe it.
MekWars
MekWars