Artwork and user interface
Moderators: Joel Billings, elmo3, Sabre21
Artwork and user interface
Hi developers and fans of WitE.
From the screen shots, I feel the map artwork is somewhat too abstract, resembling a cardboard map other than real-world terrain. And unit icons look a bit unharmonious with the map. Will it be improved further? The map of WitP:AE is a good example, more eyes appealing.
For the UI, is there a special UI designer in dev team? For such a massive game, the convenience and friendliness of UI is very important. WitP:AE is a great game but its UI is deficient. I expect WitE will be much better.
From the screen shots, I feel the map artwork is somewhat too abstract, resembling a cardboard map other than real-world terrain. And unit icons look a bit unharmonious with the map. Will it be improved further? The map of WitP:AE is a good example, more eyes appealing.
For the UI, is there a special UI designer in dev team? For such a massive game, the convenience and friendliness of UI is very important. WitP:AE is a great game but its UI is deficient. I expect WitE will be much better.
- Hard Sarge
- Posts: 22145
- Joined: Sun Oct 01, 2000 8:00 am
- Location: garfield hts ohio usa
- Contact:
RE: Artwork and user interface
greesh, the map is very pretty (spelling fails me)
if you look back though some of my posts (if you care) I showed off a number of shots of how the game has changed over the time I have been in it (I got a new computer so all of my "old" files are not in place, to easily dig them back out)
the UI ? very workable, lots of details, lots of data, with in data, you on one screen, and want more info, very easy to just get it from that screen
but over all, most games are based on menu's
most games, where the designers brag about making the UI easier, are really just dumbing down the game (Civ V, Dargons Age. Awakening, Mass Effect 2)
I think to most, when they first see the game, the map, units and UI are going to overwhelm most of them, but once you get into it, it is very easy to get to what you want, and plays well
the main Artist is PencilPusher, and he is one of the best I have seen for our type of games
if you look back though some of my posts (if you care) I showed off a number of shots of how the game has changed over the time I have been in it (I got a new computer so all of my "old" files are not in place, to easily dig them back out)
the UI ? very workable, lots of details, lots of data, with in data, you on one screen, and want more info, very easy to just get it from that screen
but over all, most games are based on menu's
most games, where the designers brag about making the UI easier, are really just dumbing down the game (Civ V, Dargons Age. Awakening, Mass Effect 2)
I think to most, when they first see the game, the map, units and UI are going to overwhelm most of them, but once you get into it, it is very easy to get to what you want, and plays well
the main Artist is PencilPusher, and he is one of the best I have seen for our type of games
RE: Artwork and user interface
ORIGINAL: jay102
Hi developers and fans of WitE.
From the screen shots, I feel the map artwork is somewhat too abstract, resembling a cardboard map other than real-world terrain. And unit icons look a bit unharmonious with the map. Will it be improved further? The map of WitP:AE is a good example, more eyes appealing.
For the UI, is there a special UI designer in dev team? For such a massive game, the convenience and friendliness of UI is very important. WitP:AE is a great game but its UI is deficient. I expect WitE will be much better.
Gotta jump in here and say I for one LOVE the map and the counters...simple and elegant. No need for further improvement in my opinion.
- Northern Star
- Posts: 1853
- Joined: Sun Feb 17, 2008 4:53 pm
RE: Artwork and user interface
The map is really good imo, about the counters... I hope you like them, I did my best to choose their colors.
RE: Artwork and user interface
I'd like to see it like Storm Over in the Pacific but, they did a much better job than the old hex games.
-
- Posts: 497
- Joined: Wed Apr 09, 2008 2:21 pm
RE: Artwork and user interface
I'd like to see it like Storm Over in the Pacific but, they did a much better job than the old hex games.
This is a joke right? [&:] If not, it should be. Storm Over in the Pacific? I actually bought that game and it has been collecting dust on my shelf after maybe 1-3 days messing around with it. IMO bad UI and average graphics. Maybe if they do some work on it in later patches I'll look at it again. It had great potential and I guess still does.
[:(]
I've been playing hex games (board and computer) for 20+ years and this is the best yet! Kudos to Gary and company. FYI: I go way back to SSI in the 80's with the pilot "Gary Grigsby's War in Russia" for Apple ]['s. Another fav was "Operation Market Garden".
How does Joel Billings still look so young? [:D] old photo at 2by3 games? Maybe Grecian Formula? [:'(]
RE: Artwork and user interface
Still needling PixelPusher are ya? [:D]ORIGINAL: Hard Sarge
the main Artist is PencilPusher, and he is one of the best I have seen for our type of games
Occasionally, and randomly, problems and solutions collide. The probability of these collisions is inversely related to the number of committees working on the solutions. -- Me.
RE: Artwork and user interface
Hi all,
This is what Goran posted in another thread... I hope this helps... [:)]
Leo "Apollo11"
ORIGINAL: jay102
I feel the map artwork is somewhat too abstract, resembling a cardboard map other than real-world terrain.
This is what Goran posted in another thread... I hope this helps... [:)]
ORIGINAL: goranw
Uploaded is a small part of a typical real German OKH- map that was widely used.
(Its the German 9th army and The Soviet positions-43)
Its easy to see some resemblence with the map in
"War in the East". I find that very inspiring. Very often
game maps are to fancy and totally unrealistic. Of course a map cant be
altogether realistic because of the need for some abstractions and game-help.
Goran
Leo "Apollo11"
Prior Preparation & Planning Prevents Pathetically Poor Performance!
A & B: WitW, WitE, WbtS, GGWaW, GGWaW2-AWD, HttR, CotA, BftB, CF
P: UV, WitP, WitP-AE
- Marc von Martial
- Posts: 5292
- Joined: Thu Jan 04, 2001 4:00 pm
- Location: Bonn, Germany
- Contact:
RE: Artwork and user interface
ORIGINAL: jay102
From the screen shots, I feel the map artwork is somewhat too abstract, resembling a cardboard map other than real-world terrain.
That was the design goal. We did not want "real" terrain for this at all.
On such a monster game a good portion of abstraction is needed for the map.
-
- Posts: 231
- Joined: Tue Nov 29, 2005 8:27 pm
RE: Artwork and user interface
Guy's if you want another map why don't you mod one to suit your own tastes then share it with us.
Great game map and counters, the download went like a dream, so smooth.
Right my request, will we be gett'in a planning map similar to WitP/AE with all the locations named I.E. dots.
Having read numerous books on the subject IMO this would enhance my gaming experience, or better still the actual game map with all locations named or would this be too cluttered.
Thanks to everyone concerned with the production of this masterpiece.
Great game map and counters, the download went like a dream, so smooth.
Right my request, will we be gett'in a planning map similar to WitP/AE with all the locations named I.E. dots.
Having read numerous books on the subject IMO this would enhance my gaming experience, or better still the actual game map with all locations named or would this be too cluttered.
Thanks to everyone concerned with the production of this masterpiece.
-
- Posts: 211
- Joined: Sun Dec 05, 2010 2:50 am
- Location: Birkerod, Denmark
RE: Artwork and user interface
Second the request for a planning map.
Names of all towns is of less importance, but something to hang on the wall so you don't miss the big picture.
I'm considering simply starting the '41 campaign, toggle units off, and then take screenshots en masse.
Not sure it'll work, but worth a shot.
Btw, if you type in 'operation Barbarossa planning map' in Google, and then press 'Maps' it guides you to Highland Hill Shrubs and Trees in Pennsylvania......
I wonder what they're planning over there. [:D]
Names of all towns is of less importance, but something to hang on the wall so you don't miss the big picture.
I'm considering simply starting the '41 campaign, toggle units off, and then take screenshots en masse.
Not sure it'll work, but worth a shot.
Btw, if you type in 'operation Barbarossa planning map' in Google, and then press 'Maps' it guides you to Highland Hill Shrubs and Trees in Pennsylvania......
I wonder what they're planning over there. [:D]
"Something is always wrong, Baldrick. The fact that I'm not a millionaire aristocrat with the sexual capacity of a rutting rhino is a constant niggle"
- Edmund Blackadder
- Edmund Blackadder
RE: Artwork and user interface
I love the map too. I wouldn't have wanted a real-terrain map like a satellite picture. Real-terrain maps are helpful in tactical games such as Close Combat, but become hopelessly cluttered and useless in strategic and operational games. As Goranw says above, the map of WITE is reminiscent of those OKW historical maps and it is definetely a plus on the immersion side. Kudos to the map design !
-
- Posts: 231
- Joined: Tue Nov 29, 2005 8:27 pm
RE: Artwork and user interface
Btw, if you type in 'operation Barbarossa planning map' in Google, and then press 'Maps' it guides you to Highland Hill Shrubs and Trees in Pennsylvania......
I wonder what they're planning over there.
A HA, MAYBE THIS WAS A US/NATO TRAINING AREA DURING THE COLD WAR.
They cordoned off a area in Kent prior to D-Day for training as it resembled Normandy.
RE: Artwork and user interface
Hi!
Until better possibilities you could download the map with frontlines in a thread above.
It has a lot of town/city names. Done on a zoom 4 map.
Goran
Until better possibilities you could download the map with frontlines in a thread above.
It has a lot of town/city names. Done on a zoom 4 map.
Goran
-
- Posts: 231
- Joined: Tue Nov 29, 2005 8:27 pm
RE: Artwork and user interface
Thanks Goran I download the frontlines map a few days back, if you guys could expand upon it with all locations named IMO this would make a excellent planning or game map.
RE: Artwork and user interface
Just to respond to the OP, I have to say I think the map and counters are best I've ever seen, including UV, WifP, and WitP/AE ... just superb.
The Beatings Will Continue Until Morale Improves
-
- Posts: 385
- Joined: Sun May 14, 2000 8:00 am
- Location: ITALY
RE: Artwork and user interface
I have to say that my first impressions were similar. The map looks 'cartoonish' and the counters seem to belong to a differently styled game.ORIGINAL: jay102
From the screen shots, I feel the map artwork is somewhat too abstract, resembling a cardboard map other than real-world terrain. And unit icons look a bit unharmonious with the map.
Now that I'm playing the game I think that these characteristics are, after all, a blessing. The "abstract" map let me immediately recognize the relevant terrain features of hexes and hexsides. A WitP look would (perhaps) have been more pleasant but, IMHO, less clear. The fact that units 'stick out' is also useful because if they would blend (colour-wise) with the map, it would be harder to tell at a glance what's going on.
So, what about this bright units/subdued map combination? Aesthetically pleasant? Don't know, too subjective. Useful? Definitely.
RE: Artwork and user interface
I'll admit that it took some getting used to for me, but I like it a lot now.
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
RE: Artwork and user interface
I love the map and I love the counters! For the first time I don't think I am going to have to go into the graphics files and change the counters to my liking. I love the cardboard look and I only use NATO symbols so it's a win, win for me.
Great job!
Great job!
*Warning: Dr. Foo is not an actual doctor.
Do not accept or follow any medical advice*
Do not accept or follow any medical advice*
-
- Posts: 385
- Joined: Sun May 14, 2000 8:00 am
- Location: ITALY
RE: Artwork and user interface
Anyway, the map should be 'patched', sooner or later, since there's a typo in the key! [:)] (Capitol for Capital)